Jump to content


  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Contact Methods

  • Website URL

Profile Information

  • Gender
  • Location
    Rocklin, CA
  • Interests
    Researching 1860s US steam navy ships. Learning to draw ship plans, including steam engines, using SolidWorks, and do 3D printing.

Recent Profile Visitors

491 profile views
  1. I found write-ups on both ships in the attached sources. If you do not have those several pages, contact me by email at craigecrouch@gmail.com; I cannot post them here because of copyright.
  2. This project has been on hold for the past 14 months, while I was caught up in a family housing project. I have hopes of resuming training on and use of Meshmixer very soon.
  3. So sorry to take six months to get back to this, but I missed it while I was on my 70-day road tour of maritime museums and Civil war battlefields. (Along the way I demonstrated the scanner set, in addition to Portsmouth (NH) Athenaeum, to model shops at Annapolis, the USN Carderock lab, the Smithsonian, Mystic Seaport, and Philadelphia's Independence Seaport Museum. I also viewed the half-hull and model collections at those museums and at MIT.) To answer your question, I tried mounting the scanner on a tripod dolly back in 2014 at Mare island Museum. It did not give better results than the handheld method. However, I was generally not successful then because I was using an underpowered (slow chip) laptop to drive the scanner. Since that time I have not tried a track or tripod, so you may very well be right! Use of the half-hull scans for taking of lines is pending, while I try out various software for rotating them and registering them to and x-y-z coordinate system. At this point, my recommendation for this pre-processing of the 3D scans is the freeware Meshmixer. I will post more later, with examples.
  4. I have been asked to recommend a general work on ship models and their history, and it stopped me cold. Now, you'd think that there are general books on every subject, but most on ship models are either: 1) technical builder's guides, or 2) photo-rich treatments of museum collections. I'm asking you all for recommendations for my friend, by posting the question "Best general book on ship models?" on this forum. I hope to have a vetted short list in several days. For now, I suggested he spend under $5 (including shipping) for a paperback edition of: Historic Ship Models (Paperback) by Wolfram ZuMondfeld This translation of the German original has way too much "how to" for him, but I recall that it includes a good review of the relationships between ships and ship models for as far back as Egypt. How about it? Do you have any other recommended general books?
  5. To help the scanner maintain tracking when scanning a large smooth surface (a half-hull over three feet, for example), I distribute little traffic cones at 1- to 2-foot intervals around the target object. If you lose tracking and imperfectly regain it, the active color image will show double cone tops -- you need to redo that scan.
  6. When taking 3D scans, I have found a free online viewer (http://www.viewstl.com/) to provide a quick and easily manipulated rendering of the stl-format scan file. You must have an active internet connection to use this viewer.
  7. BACKGROUND I became interested in scanning half-hull models as an aside from my research on a particular ship, SS Meteor (1864). I have a long-standing interest in the fast screw cruisers of the 1860s, including the Delano/Isherwood and Lenthall/Isherwood designs, and the privately-designed competitors: the USS Idaho by Steers/Dickerson, and Dennison Lawlor's SS Meteor. My interest also extends to British and French commerce-raiding and pursuit cruisers of that era: HMS Inconstant and related classes, and the four French-built Confederate raiders that became BAP América, BAP Unión, SMS Augusta, and SMS Victoria. I recently obtained a scan of the HMS Inconstant plan from The National Maritime Museum. The screw clipper Meteor (1864) was a smaller version of USS Idaho, but she had Scotish engines that delivered her promised speed. She was built by a Boston consortium to pursue Confederate commerce raiders, but was delivered too late for that purpose. The ship's trials showed her to be the fastest screw steamer in America, until the Navy tested its Isherwood-engined cruisers two years later. Despite attempts to use her in a commercial venture, the ship was really only suitable as a commerce raider, or for pursuing them. RESULTS OF TESTING THE TWO GENERATIONS OF SENSE HAND-HELD SCANNERS I have recently been successful in scanning a private half-hull of the USS Wampanoag, and the model of SS Meteor at the Portsmouth (NH) Athenaeum. In late September I will scan the larger Meteor model at the Smithsonian Institution. From these scans I will prepare traditional body, half-breadth, and sheer plans using SolidWorks. Below are my recommendations for anyone seeking to use a Sense scanner to scan half-hull models. TECH MEMO: To Recap: For best results in scanning half-hulls, I have settled upon the generation 1 Sense3D scanner, paired with a Surface Pro 2 tablet (with the faster i5-4300U processor, and 4 to 8 GB RAM) running Windows 8.1. Both these devices can now only be obtained used or refurbished, and often the Pro 2 requires an operating system reset to Win8.1 from Win10. However, the gen1 scanner has 3x3x3 meter capability and full user control of settings, vs. 2x2x2 meters and a too-friendly (impaired) interface with the generation 2 Sense2 scanner (retail: $360-400). Out of the box, you can distinguish the two generations of scanner thus: The second generation "Sense2" has and "Intel inside" logo on the base label; the original (prefered) "Sense3D" does not. The good news is that Cubify has become part of 3DSystems, and the formerly non-existent support for the Sense scanner has been replaced by exemplary 24-hour support. Software for both generations of Sense scanners (as well as the Apple variant) is found at: Www.3dsystems.com/shop/support/sense/videos [Apple users -- note that at $80 the retail price for the scanner for your OS is roughly 20 percent the cost of the Windows scanner. Go figure...] The older (gen1) scanner can be found for $200-350 on ebay -- usually in new condition, due to an initial frustration effect. The Surface Pro 2 with 4300U quad processor has a nominal speed of 1.9 GHz, but ranges up to 2.6 or 2.9 GHz. That is plenty to drive the scanner, which the box says requires 2 GHz and 4 GB. I CANNOT RECOMMEND the 4200U SP2 (1.6 GHz and up), so shop carefully. Expect to pay $300-350 for a 4300U SP2 on ebay (you may get a stylus included), or just go to Newegg and spend $330: https://www.neweggbusiness.com/product/product.aspx?item=9b-34-735-142 In either case, you will need a $35-50 Surface Pro 2 stylus, because the sensor software is MUCH easier to use with one. A mount to join the SP2 and scanner can be 3D-printed from the design at: http://www.thingiverse.com/thing:237449 OR you can contact me for my redesign of that mount (as a print file, or an actual mount).
  8. US-SteamNavy

    Other Hobbies, Interests or Pastimes that you enjoy

    For Civil War buffs, here is a link to my research on a large and little-known ship-and-shore Army mutiny at Ft. Monroe and Norfolk in June 1865. While researching the R. B. Forbes pursuit cruiser Meteor (1865), I discovered the ship had been used to transport part of the Cavalry Brigade of the 25th Corps for service on the Texas-Mexico border -- part of an army sent to intimidate the French Imperialists. I came across a newspaper story about a mutiny on board Meteor, and just kept "pulling on the thread". It's at: http://civilwartalk.com/threads/the-usct-mutiny-before-ft-monroe-june-1865.117903/#post-1202440
  9. I used a student (90-day) version of an old SolidWorks to test out, and then threw down the $$$ for the mid-range version of 2015, which includes the rendering tools. That last capability may be wishful thinking in the near-term, but I have great hopes of rendering eventually. Lately I have been gathering plans and info for the two articles that I plan: one on the screw clipper Meteor, and the second a survey of her American, Russian, British, Confederate (and ultimately Chilean, Peruvian & Prussian) contemporaries. I'm having a hard time getting plans of the four French-built (Arman) screw corvettes and the Russian screw clippers. Of course, I have plans for the Isherwood cruisers and I should have the lines of HMS Inconstant soon. I'm still hoping for news from the Smithsonian on having the lines for the Meteor taken off their half-hull model.
  10. I made the fundraiser suggestion to an NRG board member in May and again last month, so I figure that horse was led to water twice..... ANOTHER LODE OF SHIP PLANS: Last week, I found an online archive of plans from "Atlas du Génie Maritime" on the French Navy's old website, since removed:: https://web.archive.org/web/20120113075641/http://www.servicehistorique.sga.defense.gouv.fr/02fonds-collections/banquedocuments/planbato/atlas/rec.php Nifty 19th century USN ships are included.
  11. Having no interest from the NRG in the William Webb ship plans as a fund-raiser (see my first posting above), I have included those scans on the Russell Folios DVD as a bonus, with all net income (after costs and taxes) donated to the Mare Island Museum. See details at: http://modelshipworld.com/index.php/topic/11696-19th-century-ship-plans-and-renderings-now-available-from-j-scott-russell-william-h-webb-folios/
  12. Is everyone is already aware of the required Ericsson retrofit?: A "smokebox" was fitted to the muzzle of the 15-inch gun in each Passaic-class turret, to allow fire through the undersized port. The 11-inch Dahlgren (retained as in the original design) had no problem when the blast of the bigger smoothbore was contained.
  13. I am new to the forum and went through this whole posting at once. I am amazed! I am hoping to learn to do similar 3D modeling using SolidWorks but my ships would be 1860s steamers. Yours is a really astounding effort!

About us

Modelshipworld - Advancing Ship Modeling through Research

SSL Secured

Your security is important for us so this Website is SSL-Secured

NRG Mailing Address

Nautical Research Guild
237 South Lincoln Street
Westmont IL, 60559-1917

About the NRG

If you enjoy building ship models that are historically accurate as well as beautiful, then The Nautical Research Guild (NRG) is just right for you.

The Guild is a non-profit educational organization whose mission is to provide support to our members in their efforts to raise the quality of their model shipcraft.

The Nautical Research Guild puts on ship modeling seminars, yearly conferences, and juried competitions. We publish books on ship modeling techniques as well as our world-renowned quarterly magazine, The Nautical Research Journal, whose pages are full of articles by master ship modelers who show you how they build those exquisite details on their models, and by maritime historians who show you what details to build.

Our Emblem

Modelshipworld - Advancing Ship Modeling through Research