Jump to content

Which Brand of Wooden ship model kit is better or worse.....? Take a poll and answer a few multiple choice questions.


Chuck

Which Brand of Wooden ship model kits is your.....? Take a poll and answer a few multiple choice questions.  

476 members have voted

  1. 1. Which Brand of Wooden ship model kits have the best quality materials ?

    • Model Shipways
      104
    • A. Latina
      43
    • Amati
      98
    • Caldercraft
      135
    • Corel
      35
    • Constructo
      8
    • Mantua/Sergal
      22
    • Mamoli
      16
    • Occre
      44
    • Billings
      16
    • Marisstella
      20
    • Bluejacket
      64
    • Deagostini
      11
    • Dumas
      4
    • Panart
      22
    • Dusek
      16
    • Euromodel
      37
    • Master Korabel
      25
    • Modellers Shipyard
      11
    • AJ Fisher
      5
    • Soclaine
      0
    • Syren Ship Model Company
      129
    • The Lum ber Yard
      4
    • Kolderstok
      6
    • Vanguard Models
      38
    • Disarmodel
      0
    • WoodyJoe
      3
    • CAFModel
      3
  2. 2. Which Brand of Wooden ship model kits have the best quality plans and are historically accurate to the best of your knowledge?

    • Model Shipways
      164
    • A. Latina
      23
    • Amati
      71
    • Caldercraft
      144
    • Corel
      12
    • Constructo
      3
    • Mantua/Sergal
      10
    • Mamoli
      16
    • Occre
      29
    • Billings
      17
    • Marisstella
      18
    • Bluejacket
      58
    • Deagostini
      10
    • Dumas
      6
    • Panart
      7
    • Dusek
      10
    • Euromodel
      37
    • Master Korabel
      14
    • Modellers Shipyard
      19
    • AJ Fisher
      6
    • Soclaine
      0
    • Syren Ship Model Company
      128
    • The The Lum ber Yard
      3
    • Kolderstok
      8
    • Vanguard Models
      42
    • Disarmodel
      0
    • WoodyJoe
      0
    • CAFModel
      3
  3. 3. Which Brand of Wooden ship model kits is in your opinion the best value for the $$$$

    • Model Shipways
      164
    • A. Latina
      66
    • Amati
      62
    • Caldercraft
      92
    • Corel
      16
    • Constructo
      11
    • Mantua/Sergal
      12
    • Mamoli
      14
    • Occre
      41
    • Billings
      19
    • Marisstella
      16
    • Bluejacket
      30
    • Deagostini
      8
    • Dumas
      5
    • Panart
      13
    • Dusek
      12
    • Euromodel
      12
    • Master Korabel
      20
    • Modellers Shipyard
      9
    • AJ Fisher
      5
    • Syren Ship Model Company
      98
    • The Lum ber Yard
      2
    • Kolderstok
      3
    • Vanguard Models
      28
    • Disarmodel
      0
    • WoodyJoe
      0
    • CAFModel
      1
  4. 4. Which Brand of Wooden ship model kits have do you think have the worst plans, poor quality materials, and poor instructions?

    • Model Shipways
      23
    • A. Latina
      127
    • Amati
      24
    • Caldercraft
      3
    • Corel
      51
    • Constructo
      76
    • Mantua/Sergal
      49
    • Mamoli
      58
    • Occre
      27
    • Billings
      85
    • Marisstella
      6
    • Bluejacket
      16
    • Deagostini
      12
    • Dumas
      13
    • Panart
      25
    • Dusek
      6
    • Euromodel
      10
    • Master Korabel
      8
    • Modellers Shipyard
      5
    • AJ Fisher
      2
    • Soclaine
      8
    • Syren Ship Model Company
      0
    • The Lum ber Yard
      49
    • Kolderstok
      4
    • Vanguard Models
      1
    • Disarmodel
      0
    • WoodyJoe
      1
    • CAFModel
      3


Recommended Posts

Please select up to three choices for each question.  This will help model builders trying to decide which brands are worth looking into.  Companies no longer in business or making kits.  Let me know if I missed any and I will add them to the list.  This is a list of Legitimate ship model companies. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oops! I tried to vote Marisstella for best plans having spent a few hours going over them this week.   I must have hit Bluejacket by mistake - I have no experience with Bluejacket so my vote is not informed!

Doug

Current BuildsBluenose II - AKrabbenkutter / Prince de Neufchatel / Essex Cross-section / Syren / Barque Stefano / Winchelsea / Half Hull / Maria HF31 - Dusek / Bandirma - Turkmodel

On the Shelf: Santisima Trinidad and Cross Section / HMS Cutter Alert / Tender AVOS / Confederacy

Suspended Build: Bluenose II - Billing Boats Nr 600 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Do you see a button to show vote options.....then just select again.   I think.    This poll stuff is new in this version.  Let me see.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

22 minutes ago, Chuck said:

You should be able to change your votes.

yep, thanks

 

Doug

Current BuildsBluenose II - AKrabbenkutter / Prince de Neufchatel / Essex Cross-section / Syren / Barque Stefano / Winchelsea / Half Hull / Maria HF31 - Dusek / Bandirma - Turkmodel

On the Shelf: Santisima Trinidad and Cross Section / HMS Cutter Alert / Tender AVOS / Confederacy

Suspended Build: Bluenose II - Billing Boats Nr 600 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pity I haven't done more kits...only 3.   Sadly, the one kit that I really loved was the Billings Wasa and it's apparently no longer available.  Excellent and historically accurate plans but crappy wood and quality control..  <sigh.

Mark
"The shipwright is slow, but the wood is patient." - me

Current Build:                                                                                             
Past Builds:
 La Belle Poule 1765 - French Frigate from ANCRE plans - ON HOLD           Triton Cross-Section   

 NRG Hallf Hull Planking Kit                                                                            HMS Sphinx 1775 - Vanguard Models - 1:64               

 

Non-Ship Model:                                                                                         On hold, maybe forever:           

CH-53 Sikorsky - 1:48 - Revell - Completed                                                   Licorne - 1755 from Hahn Plans (Scratch) Version 2.0 (Abandoned)         

         

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mark, who says it's unavailable? Billing Boats USA has them in stock, and they're still listed on the Billingboats.com.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My bad.  I hadn't been able to see their product listing for so long, I thought they were gone.   

Mark
"The shipwright is slow, but the wood is patient." - me

Current Build:                                                                                             
Past Builds:
 La Belle Poule 1765 - French Frigate from ANCRE plans - ON HOLD           Triton Cross-Section   

 NRG Hallf Hull Planking Kit                                                                            HMS Sphinx 1775 - Vanguard Models - 1:64               

 

Non-Ship Model:                                                                                         On hold, maybe forever:           

CH-53 Sikorsky - 1:48 - Revell - Completed                                                   Licorne - 1755 from Hahn Plans (Scratch) Version 2.0 (Abandoned)         

         

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Maybe you should include the question on how many different brands each voter has had experience with.

In the Australian hobby shops the majority of models available are from Artesania Latina. I have only used one other brand. So I can only compare and vote for the 2, which doesn't do justice to the better quality kits I don't know about.

Current Build:     USF Confederacy 1778 - Model Shipways - 1:64

 

Completed:         US Brig Syren - Model Shipways - 1:64

                        San Francisco Cross Section - Artesania Latina - 1:50

Future build:        HM Granado - Caldercraft - 1:64

                        LeRenard - Artesania Latina - 1:50

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I understand,  but you need not actually build some of these kits to know about their details.   For example,  I have never built a Dusek kit before.  But I have seen them up close, both here on MSW and in person.  The quality of the laser cutting and the materials supplied is excellent.  Some of the best I have seen in a kit model.  So I would be very comfortable voting for them.  

 

Other than that I think folks should just vote their experience....whatever the reason.  For example,  if you did buy an AL kit because its all that was available to you and you found the plans and instructions terrible,  dont vote for them.  A "NO" vote is just as important as a "Yes Vote"

 

I have never bought or seen a Soclaine kit up close.  I dont know anything about them.   So I will not vote for them but instead I will just vote for what I do know about to the best of my knowledge.  You dont need personal experience with all of the brands on the list.  These results shouldnt correlate with the number of build logs for that exact reason.  More of one brand in a lot of build logs could be about availability while this poll is about other aspects for the brands based on the best of your knowledge,  whether from online viewing or from personal experience.

 

In addition,  the internet allows us to buy other brands that might not be available locally.  Hopefully that will help give folks an introduction to these kits.  As far as Australia is concerned,  that explains a lot about why the Chinese kits are so prevalent there.  Right or wrong but availability is a huge consideration and the expense to ship products there.  In the states here I have not bought a hobby kit or product in any brick and mortar store for ten years.  I have always bought them online and had them shipped.  There are zero hobby shops within 100 miles of me that actually carry anything ship model related.....

 

I think it is understood that most people wont have experience with many of the brands listed.  Rather than have them list which ones they have had experience with I think maybe a question asking which kit brand you have had a bad experience with would be better.  You can select those you thought had poor materials, plans and instructions.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Based on a suggestion this topic was moved to this forum.  A very good suggestion, thank you. :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think Kolderstok deserves to be on the list. :)

 

http://www.kolderstok-models.com/index.en.html

WIP: No ships atm...sorry!🙄

Completed: Greek bireme - Dusek - scale 1:72

 Louie da fly: "I think it requires a special kind of insanity to choose a galley to build a model of."

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would have broken things out a little more.  Some kits for example have good plans but poor materials.  Some have poor plans but good materials.

 

I’d also note the results may not be fair to certain kit manufacturers.  For example, there aren’t many Billings or Bluejacket builds on here.  And the Lumberyard kit is a whole different kind of kit from the more retail mass market kit.

Edited by Landlubber Mike

Mike

 

Current Wooden builds:  Amati/Victory Pegasus  MS Charles W. Morgan  Euromodel La Renommèe  

 

Plastic builds:    Hs129B-2 1/48  SB2U-1 Vindicator 1/48  Five Star Yaeyama 1/700  Pit Road Asashio and Akashi 1/700 diorama  Walrus 1/48 and Albatross 1/700  Special Hobby Buffalo 1/32   IJN Notoro 1/700  Akitsu Maru 1/700

 

Completed builds :  Caldercraft Brig Badger   Amati Hannah - Ship in Bottle  Pit Road Hatsuzakura 1/700   Hasegawa Shimakaze 1:350

F4B-4 and P-6E 1/72  Accurate Miniatures F3F-1/F3F-2 1/48  Tamiya F4F-4 Wildcat built as FM-1 1/48  Special Hobby Buffalo 1/48  Eduard Sikorsky JRS-1 1/72

Citroen 2CV 1/24 - Airfix and Tamiya  Entex Morgan 3-wheeler 1/16

 

Terminated build:  HMS Lyme (based on Corel Unicorn)  

 

On the shelf:  Euromodel Friedrich Wilhelm zu Pferde; Caldercraft Victory; too many plastic ship, plane and car kits

 

Future potential scratch builds:  HMS Lyme (from NMM plans); Le Gros Ventre (from Ancre monographs), Dutch ship from Ab Hoving book, HMS Sussex from McCardle book, Philadelphia gunboat (Smithsonian plans)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 months later...

Giving this a bump!!!!  If you havent taken the poll yet.  Please do.  Lets capture more data for folks making a decision on which kits to buy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
  • 2 weeks later...
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 weeks later...
On ‎28‎/‎09‎/‎2017 at 1:48 PM, Peter Bloemendaal said:

Maybe you should include the question on how many different brands each voter has had experience with.

In the Australian hobby shops the majority of models available are from Artesania Latina. I have only used one other brand. So I can only compare and vote for the 2, which doesn't do justice to the better quality kits I don't know about.

My thoughts exactly
Don't think this poll is fair as it only takes into account votes polled
So if 1 person has voted for, say, Euromodels (ie Victory Models) and no body else has built a Victory MOdels kit then it is TOTALLY misleading

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Richardjjs said:

My thoughts exactly
Don't think this poll is fair as it only takes into account votes polled
So if 1 person has voted for, say, Euromodels (ie Victory Models) and no body else has built a Victory MOdels kit then it is TOTALLY misleading

 

 

That is the issue with all opinion polling.  This one is a nice quick snapshot of what the members who voted think about the kit companies.  Recognizing the limitations, few meaningful conclusions, and certainly few statistical measures (standard error, things like that) are possible.

 

It is, surprisingly enough, the same with those amazing opinion polls we see, where they polled 1000 likely voters (or similar qualifying characteristic).  While you can say that x% were in favor of something, tge plus or minus y percentage points is NOT so accurate - they base that on questions which they infer to indicate how you REALLY feel about something.  It is silly how much emohasis folks place on those polls!  1000 people represent accurately the opinions of 200 million?

 

 

 

Wayne

Neither should a ship rely on one small anchor, nor should life rest on a single hope.
Epictetus

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is a snapshot of what folks feel is the best or worst kit.  It is based on their experiences.  I would be inclined to say it is very fair.   Folks shouldnt read into it so much.  We ask folks what they like based on their experience and what they dont like.  They are voting honestly and that data collected is very good and very useful for others wanting to get an idea of what one of these MFGs are like.  

 

Some people want to over complicate things like this poll ..... it is ....what it is.  And very useful.  Certainly the kits built more will have higher numbers....but that doesnt mean the data is incorrect.  If fewer people have built a brand of kit and all of the polling indicates that it was a good experience then that data is worth knowing.   If a company has a high percentage of unfavorable votes, no matter how much market share they have,   I think that is very good to know.   Dont over think it.

 

If you have a differing opinion based on your experience then vote......the numbers either way are a very honest and accurate depiction.

 

Remember...you shouldnt look at this poll as a way to judge a winner like its a horse race.   You should look at this poll as an indication of what people think about the one brand they voted on.   If you only have access to AL kits from brick and mortar stores and think they are awful then let us know.  If you think they are wonderful.....let us know.   The reason why a company like AL has such high negatives is based on that personal experience.  It will certainly help someone who wants to build something better without worrying about being disappointed after buying a kit with no review or polling.  With the internet, all brands are available anywhere....it may cost more but a poll like this may give someone a reason to pay a bit more for one if they have great polling vs. bad polling.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...

I'd just like to add that it would be immensely useful, especially for people just starting their journey (like me) if this thread was accessible for everyone and not just registered users.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Peter Y. said:

I'd just like to add that it would be immensely useful, especially for people just starting their journey (like me) if this thread was accessible for everyone and not just registered users.

Ah, but tidbits like this are exactly why we encourage people to come in out of the cold and become registered users! ;)

Chris Coyle
Greer, South Carolina

When you have to shoot, shoot. Don't talk.
- Tuco

Current builds: Brigantine Phoenix, Bf 109E-7/trop

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, ccoyle said:

Ah, but tidbits like this are exactly why we encourage people to come in out of the cold and become registered users! ;)

If that's the case make the poll visible for everyone but the results only to registered users ;-) I bet you'd get better results.

35 minutes ago, Azzoun said:

Registration is free- so what's the big deal about doing it to get full access?

Well...

 

First off one would have to know that it exists and there's no way to find out without registering.

 

Secondly - it's an additional step and although it doesn't seem like much it may put some people off. Of course to verify this one would have to look at the site analytics (e.g. number of new unique visits vs. number of new registration requests).

 

Thirdly - I don't know about other people but I don't just go out and give my e-mail address to any site that might come in handy. Especially if I'm (in this case) new to the hobby and still unsure whether I'll still be interested in a few weeks time.

 

Lastly - Note that there are a lot more valuable resources available to view or even download from the site than this poll, so keeping it hidden away seems unreasonable.

 

This is just my subjective opinion - I've decided to register because this site has a great community and I'm certain that there are many people here that will help me with my first build. The fact is though that at some point after registering I've stumbled upon this poll and just thought to myself that it's genuinely useful - if I knew it existed I would probably register a couple of weeks ago rather than just now.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...