Soclaine vs Artesania Latina "Le Renard"

[grsjax]

I have been looking at kits of cutters and have found two that are of the same vessel in the same scale and about the same price.  One is the Soclaine 1:50 scale Le Renard and the other is the 1:50 scale Artesania Latina model of the same ship.  First impression is both kits are about the same but I know that can be wrong so here goes.

Question: Which of these models is the better choice?  Quality, instructions, fittings, historical accuracy and general fit and finish?

 

I found the build logs and gallery photos of both models but they were not real helpful in making a buying decision.