dcicero

USS Cairo is a fascinating vessel and I'm thrilled to see a build log for her.  I visited the Vicksburg NMP for the first time about 20 years ago.  I've been back twice since and it's an amazing place.  Grant's Vicksburg Campaign was the most complex and successful of the war and the more one learns about it the more amazing it becomes.  Outside of professional military circles, I don't think it gets the attention it deserves.  Inside military circles, it does.  The U.S. Army used the campaign as a model of operational warfare until the first Gulf War when it was replaced in the field manuals with General Schwarzkopf's campaign in Iraq.
 
I'm really looking forward to your build!
 
 
Dan



 
 

I've been pokey about posting more updates here on MSW.  Work has consumed all my time over the past several weeks, so any time I get to spend at the bench is a real luxury.  I'm thankful every day for the work, but it is draining.
 
When last I posted, I'd just gotten the planking belts laid out.  It took some time to get that right, but it finally did come together.  I also took the opportunity to do more fairing.  It seems that's a never-quite-ending task, but a ncecessary one to avoid high and low spots.

Then I made my tic-strips for each of the frames.  Once I made these, I stored them in a little ziplock bag.  Don't lose them!  You'll need them again and again.
 
Per the instructions I used both methods to lay out the planking.  When I used the first method, I thought, "why in the world hadn't I thought of this before."  It made a lot of sense and was easy to do.
 

I didn't know it at this point, but, as clever as this method is, I got better results, faster, with the second method.  In any event, things went well.
 

Carving and sanding these very narrow planks was a little challenging.  I ruined a couple of them doing that, but eventually landed on this method.  Just clamp them in a self-locking pliers like this, with a piece of scrap stock on the bottom of them to keep them from moving around, and sand away.  I found I could keep them stable, see what I was doing and get a good result doing this.
 

Here's the first belt in place.



I think the first plank above the broad strake was too narrow.  I discovered that too late, so the next couple of planks are probably a little wider than they should be.  That's a live and learn, I think.  One great thing about this model is that ever run of planks is better than the one before it.  I've really noted an improvement in my skills as I've gone along, which is the purpose of a tutorial like this.
 
The stealer was next.  Toni says you'll be lucky to get this right in three tries.  I was.  I got it right in two. The first was a complete disaster and had to be removed...
 

With that gaping hole in my model -- and, you'll note -- the gap just where the stealer would have to be glued in, I plugged ahead.  Toni does say to install a block in between the frames, but what I failed to do was extend that block below the top edge of the plank.  I've got plenty of gluing surface where I don't need it in this picture, and none where I do.  Removing the first stealer to fix it allowed me to fix this whole issue.
 

And there it is.
 
Since this, I've laid out the second belt of planking and made my next set of tick strips.  Lots more planking to do.
 
 
Dan
 
 
 
 

Thank you, Gentlemen.  I'm glad you're enjoying the build log.  To the question about how I'm going to mount it, I would like to do it in the traditional half hull manner, on a wood backplate.  I'm concerned about the appearance of the top of the model though.  I don't want it to look like a construction site, which would happen if I left the tops of the frames exposed.  I'll need to do some thinking about this as the project progresses.
 
With the garboard strake in place, I moved on to the broad strake.  This plank took more work than the garboard strake.  I made three aft planks before getting one that I could install.  The fundamental problem is the amount of twist in these planks.  Of the three, the midships plank is the easiest to lay-out and install because there's very little twist in it.  Not only was it difficult to lay out the forward and aft planks with the Tamiya tape, but it was also hard to test fit them to make sure they would fit.
 
For the forward plank, Toni's instructions say, "mark the sternpost, dead flat frame and bow for the top of the strake and run a piece of tape to represent the top of the planking.  Again, be careful not to let the fore end of the planking run too high up the stem."  For the garboard -- and as I started laying out the broad strake -- I layed the tape out and then marked every frame, measuring all along, but with the instruction to not "let the fore end of the planking run too high up the stem," I came to the conclusions that this is a much less rigorous, analytical process than I had thought. It comes down to mark three spots and then eyeball it in.  Once I'd made that leap, layout got easier.
 
Now to that torsion issue, I've built with basswood before and it bends really nicely -- it even edge-bends nicely -- when simply wetted down with some warm water.  The heat of your hands working it is all that's needed, no fancy plank benders or anything.  After trying to horse the plank in place, I decided to just do that.  It's not mentioned anywhere in the instructions, but it certainly helped me.  I clamped the plank in place and let it dry.  When it was dry, I removed it, applied glue and set it in place without all kinds of force.  Toni does mention, earlier in the instructions, to be careful of putting dents in the wood.  That's easy to do and I did it.  I've since been working that little dent out by applying some water and letting the grain expand. You can see it in the second photo below.
 


The center plank, because there isn't much twist in it, is easy to lay out and install.  The after one, where there's the most twist, I found hard to lay out.  It took me three tries with the third time the charm.  Same procedure though.  Lay it out with the Tamiya tape and cut the plank.  Wet it to make it more pliable and clamp it in place.  Remove it when dry -- and here's the tricky part -- sand, fit, sand, fit, sand, fit, repeat as necessary until it's right.  In the end, I'm very happy with how that plank looks and the run of the broad strake, but it was more work than I anticipated.
 
You can see in this photo the amount of twist in that plank.

Here it is clamped in place.
 

And here's the finished result.
 



 
 
Dan
 
 

Well, two steps forward, one step back.
 
On Friday night, I got this from Kurt Van Dahm, President of our club, the Nautical Research and Model Ship Society of Chicago and NRG Director:  "A good indication that the Garboard plank is correct is to look at it at 90 deg to the keel piece and it should be a straight line fore to aft w/o the bow end rising.  It looks good from the head on view down the length."
 
So, I decided to check and, by that measure, my garboard strake needs work.

You can see that it does rise up at the forward end.
 
I've used Titebond on this model, which can be removed with isopropyl (rubbing) alcohol, which, around here anyway, is about as common in the grocery store as weapons-grade plutonium.  I had to come up with another way to correct this problem.
 
First thing I did was lay out that straight line with pinstriping tape.
 

Looking down at that line from as close to 90 degrees as I can get shows the problem at the bow.  I marked off the rise with a pencil and then, using a flexible ruler as a guide, cut off the part that needed to be removed.


You can see just a tiny bit of the strake still stuck to the keel, in the rabbet.  The rest of the strake came off easily because there really wasn't much adhesive holding it on.  At the extreme end, that wasn't the case.  Without isopropyl alcohol to soften this up, what could I do?  Normally, I would just use my heat gun on this, but this part of the model is, I thought, too delicate for that.  So I fired up my soldering iron to apply some focused heat to the area.  That did the trick.  Took the little piece of remaining strake right off.
 
I think it would be good to add a note about that "straight line when viewed 90 degrees to the keel" tip in the instructions.  Sure helped me see where my error was.  Toni does mention that her garboard strake ended about 0.90" from AF.  I was confused by that because mine ended farther forward than that.  Now I understand why.  After removing the rise in the strake, that 0.90" measurement makes a lot more sense.  You can see that mine now ends where it's supposed to.

 
 
Dan

I've installed the forward part of the garboard strake.  Really nothing hard about this at all.  I used the same process I did for the aft portion.
 
For clamping it down I used the same technique, but his time with the metal strip removed from an old windshield wiper blade.  That thing has found many uses in my shop.
 

Here you can see the complete garboard strake.

And here's a detail look at the bow.

And a look along the run of the plank.

All coming along nicely now.  I measured and marked out the broad strake last night.  I'll cut, carve and install at least part of it tonight.
 
 
 
Dan
 
 
 

The fairing of the stern was the most challenging part of the job so far.  There's some serious shaping that has to take place there.
 
And just when I thought I was done with all that, more opportunities popped up!
 
The first thing I did was plot out where the garboard strake would be.

That was easily done and then I laid a piece of pinstriping tape along those lines and checked them for fair.  I could see there were more high and low spots that needed attention.
 

So I spent more time fairing and getting that line where I wanted it.  This is a tedious process, but necessary, I think.
 
When I got it where I wanted it...

...then I laid out the garboard strake on some Tamiya tape.  I only had a roll of the 6 mm tape and this job really requires the 10 mm tape, but in these days of COVID-19, I didn't feel like running to the hobby shop (about a 30 minute drive, too) for that.  I ordered some online, but then just improvised a little.  I used two lengths of tape and just overlapped them a little.  You can kind of see that in the picture.  The important thing is what Toni points out.  You can see through the Tamiya tape, which allows you to see the marks made on the frames.
 

Here's the garboard strake with the tape removed.
 
 There was some final shaping to do on the strake and then gluing it in place.  That requires some thought too.  Getting the aft part of the strake to lay flat against the deadwood is a tricky clamping job unless you have some of those really long nosed clamps that Toni has.  I don't, so I improvised with a couple of pieces of scrap wood.  (Yes, that's walnut.  Very upscale scrap wood!)
 

And here's the final product.
 

The forward part of the strake went in tonight, much easier than the after part, I though.  I haven't uploaded those pictures yet, so stay tuned.
 
 
Dan
 
 
 
 

I know it's been a while since I posted any updates.  I have made progress!
 
You can see here the second planking belt completed and the first layer of the wale installed.
 

 
It took me a couple of tries to get this right, but I was pretty happy with how it turned out.
 

 
Notice anything weird?  All that black staining?
 
The instructions recommend using an archival marker to stain the edges of the wale, so went over to Hobby Lobby and bought one.  I was really happy with how that went.  It looks like paint and is a lot less hassle.  I'd fitted the two pieces of the wale by wetting them, clamping them in place and letting them dry.  I removed them, used the marker and then let them dry for a day before reinstalling as you can see here.  Every time I touched the model, some of that black ink would come off on my hands.  I tried cleaning it off with a cottom swab and you can see the result below.  What a mess.
 

 
I'm so close to finishing this project off and the last thing I wanted was to ruin everything by bleeding black ink everywhere.  I decided to remove the wale and make a new one.  I used the old one as the template.
 

 

 

 
Even though I've removed the wale, there is still a little of that black ink on the frames.  I've been carefully removing it, but that looks to be a project that's going to take a while.
 
Anyone got any thoughts on where I went wrong? 
 
 
Dan  
 

I've been pokey about posting more updates here on MSW.  Work has consumed all my time over the past several weeks, so any time I get to spend at the bench is a real luxury.  I'm thankful every day for the work, but it is draining.
 
When last I posted, I'd just gotten the planking belts laid out.  It took some time to get that right, but it finally did come together.  I also took the opportunity to do more fairing.  It seems that's a never-quite-ending task, but a ncecessary one to avoid high and low spots.

Then I made my tic-strips for each of the frames.  Once I made these, I stored them in a little ziplock bag.  Don't lose them!  You'll need them again and again.
 
Per the instructions I used both methods to lay out the planking.  When I used the first method, I thought, "why in the world hadn't I thought of this before."  It made a lot of sense and was easy to do.
 

I didn't know it at this point, but, as clever as this method is, I got better results, faster, with the second method.  In any event, things went well.
 

Carving and sanding these very narrow planks was a little challenging.  I ruined a couple of them doing that, but eventually landed on this method.  Just clamp them in a self-locking pliers like this, with a piece of scrap stock on the bottom of them to keep them from moving around, and sand away.  I found I could keep them stable, see what I was doing and get a good result doing this.
 

Here's the first belt in place.



I think the first plank above the broad strake was too narrow.  I discovered that too late, so the next couple of planks are probably a little wider than they should be.  That's a live and learn, I think.  One great thing about this model is that ever run of planks is better than the one before it.  I've really noted an improvement in my skills as I've gone along, which is the purpose of a tutorial like this.
 
The stealer was next.  Toni says you'll be lucky to get this right in three tries.  I was.  I got it right in two. The first was a complete disaster and had to be removed...
 

With that gaping hole in my model -- and, you'll note -- the gap just where the stealer would have to be glued in, I plugged ahead.  Toni does say to install a block in between the frames, but what I failed to do was extend that block below the top edge of the plank.  I've got plenty of gluing surface where I don't need it in this picture, and none where I do.  Removing the first stealer to fix it allowed me to fix this whole issue.
 

And there it is.
 
Since this, I've laid out the second belt of planking and made my next set of tick strips.  Lots more planking to do.
 
 
Dan
 
 
 
 

Thank you, Gentlemen.  I'm glad you're enjoying the build log.  To the question about how I'm going to mount it, I would like to do it in the traditional half hull manner, on a wood backplate.  I'm concerned about the appearance of the top of the model though.  I don't want it to look like a construction site, which would happen if I left the tops of the frames exposed.  I'll need to do some thinking about this as the project progresses.
 
With the garboard strake in place, I moved on to the broad strake.  This plank took more work than the garboard strake.  I made three aft planks before getting one that I could install.  The fundamental problem is the amount of twist in these planks.  Of the three, the midships plank is the easiest to lay-out and install because there's very little twist in it.  Not only was it difficult to lay out the forward and aft planks with the Tamiya tape, but it was also hard to test fit them to make sure they would fit.
 
For the forward plank, Toni's instructions say, "mark the sternpost, dead flat frame and bow for the top of the strake and run a piece of tape to represent the top of the planking.  Again, be careful not to let the fore end of the planking run too high up the stem."  For the garboard -- and as I started laying out the broad strake -- I layed the tape out and then marked every frame, measuring all along, but with the instruction to not "let the fore end of the planking run too high up the stem," I came to the conclusions that this is a much less rigorous, analytical process than I had thought. It comes down to mark three spots and then eyeball it in.  Once I'd made that leap, layout got easier.
 
Now to that torsion issue, I've built with basswood before and it bends really nicely -- it even edge-bends nicely -- when simply wetted down with some warm water.  The heat of your hands working it is all that's needed, no fancy plank benders or anything.  After trying to horse the plank in place, I decided to just do that.  It's not mentioned anywhere in the instructions, but it certainly helped me.  I clamped the plank in place and let it dry.  When it was dry, I removed it, applied glue and set it in place without all kinds of force.  Toni does mention, earlier in the instructions, to be careful of putting dents in the wood.  That's easy to do and I did it.  I've since been working that little dent out by applying some water and letting the grain expand. You can see it in the second photo below.
 


The center plank, because there isn't much twist in it, is easy to lay out and install.  The after one, where there's the most twist, I found hard to lay out.  It took me three tries with the third time the charm.  Same procedure though.  Lay it out with the Tamiya tape and cut the plank.  Wet it to make it more pliable and clamp it in place.  Remove it when dry -- and here's the tricky part -- sand, fit, sand, fit, sand, fit, repeat as necessary until it's right.  In the end, I'm very happy with how that plank looks and the run of the broad strake, but it was more work than I anticipated.
 
You can see in this photo the amount of twist in that plank.

Here it is clamped in place.
 

And here's the finished result.
 



 
 
Dan
 
 

Well, two steps forward, one step back.
 
On Friday night, I got this from Kurt Van Dahm, President of our club, the Nautical Research and Model Ship Society of Chicago and NRG Director:  "A good indication that the Garboard plank is correct is to look at it at 90 deg to the keel piece and it should be a straight line fore to aft w/o the bow end rising.  It looks good from the head on view down the length."
 
So, I decided to check and, by that measure, my garboard strake needs work.

You can see that it does rise up at the forward end.
 
I've used Titebond on this model, which can be removed with isopropyl (rubbing) alcohol, which, around here anyway, is about as common in the grocery store as weapons-grade plutonium.  I had to come up with another way to correct this problem.
 
First thing I did was lay out that straight line with pinstriping tape.
 

Looking down at that line from as close to 90 degrees as I can get shows the problem at the bow.  I marked off the rise with a pencil and then, using a flexible ruler as a guide, cut off the part that needed to be removed.


You can see just a tiny bit of the strake still stuck to the keel, in the rabbet.  The rest of the strake came off easily because there really wasn't much adhesive holding it on.  At the extreme end, that wasn't the case.  Without isopropyl alcohol to soften this up, what could I do?  Normally, I would just use my heat gun on this, but this part of the model is, I thought, too delicate for that.  So I fired up my soldering iron to apply some focused heat to the area.  That did the trick.  Took the little piece of remaining strake right off.
 
I think it would be good to add a note about that "straight line when viewed 90 degrees to the keel" tip in the instructions.  Sure helped me see where my error was.  Toni does mention that her garboard strake ended about 0.90" from AF.  I was confused by that because mine ended farther forward than that.  Now I understand why.  After removing the rise in the strake, that 0.90" measurement makes a lot more sense.  You can see that mine now ends where it's supposed to.

 
 
Dan

I've installed the forward part of the garboard strake.  Really nothing hard about this at all.  I used the same process I did for the aft portion.
 
For clamping it down I used the same technique, but his time with the metal strip removed from an old windshield wiper blade.  That thing has found many uses in my shop.
 

Here you can see the complete garboard strake.

And here's a detail look at the bow.

And a look along the run of the plank.

All coming along nicely now.  I measured and marked out the broad strake last night.  I'll cut, carve and install at least part of it tonight.
 
 
 
Dan
 
 
 

I got a little more time over the weekend to make some progress on the planking project.  I sawed off the excess at the tops of the frames.
 

I'm not completely happy with the results I achieved.  When I lay a batten on the tops of the frames, there are gaps.  I think I'm going to correct these before I move along too far.
 

I started fairing the hull.  I added some black lines to the centers of the frames, as Toni has suggested here on MSW.
 

I can see this is going to take a while to get right and I think I'm going to add some wood to at least some of the frames.  As you can see below, either Frame 2 is too proud or Frame 1 needs to be built up.  Looking at it, I think Frame 1 needs to be built up.  I can't explain why it turned out this way.  The bottom of the frame sits just as it should against the building board.  The notch in the keel is the correct depth.  It's just a mystery to me.  I started fairing, but was taking off more wood than I thought I should.  Like Toni says in the instructions, this step takes a while and requires some care and frequent checking, so I'm prepared to put in some effort on this.

 
Dan
 

One last little detail had to be taken care of on the bow:  addition of a shim that closes the gap between Frame 5A and the rabbet.  I cut a shim from a piece of basswood.
 

And installed it.
 

Then on to the stern, I installed the transom.
 


And that completes all the frames.
 

I noticed when I tried to draw in the topline, that Frame 2 was just barely tall enough.  I added a little shim to that.  Most of it will be removed when the frames are cut down, but I wanted to be able to cut down to something, not just leave it as it was.
 

I went over to Michael's -- a local craft store -- to get some chart tape.  The clerk gave me the RCA Victor dog look.
 

Seems you have to go to a "real art store" for that kind of thing.  The nearest one is quite a drive, so I decided to go to the auto parts store and see what they had.  Sure enough:  pinstriping tape.
 

Got a roll of this for about $4.00.
 
Then I marked the topline on the model and blackened the area that needs to be removed.
 


There is going to be a lot of fairing to be done on this hull.  Some of the frames are too far inboard and the curve of the hull...  Well, it was hard getting that chart tape on because the differences between the frames was very great.  Time for a lot of cutting and chopping now.
 
 
 
Dan
 
 
 

The next step required some surgery to Frame 4A.  As you can see on the errata sheet included with the kit, Frame 4A needs a little wood added to it to bring it to the right shape.  I had some 1/16" basswood in my wood pile which I used to make these modifications.  I needed three layers to get it right.
 

Here's the finished product.

And here it is installed.  A little trickier to get the clamps in there.

Then I installed the spacers.
 

The next frame (5A) is a little tricky to install.  There is no notch in the keelson for this frame because cutting one would have made the keelson too thin.  I followed Toni's directions on this, extending the lines for Frame 5a onto the keelson and then figuring out where the notch has to be to get the forward corner of the frame almost to the keel rabbet.  You can see where I cut the keelson away and cut the notch.
 


In the end, a little of the bottom of the frame chipped off.  I needed to sand it a little to get the back of the frame to contact the building board.  Rather than shim it up, I decided to cut it down...  I hope that was a good call.
 
Finally, I installed Frame 5a, the final forward frame.  (Enough alliteration for you?)
 

 
Dan
 
 

As per the instructions on Page 13, I glued "frames E through 4 to the keelson and the building board" and installed the spacers between them.  That, as the instructions said, took some trimming and shimming to get right.

One thing I'm a little concerned about is the snaggle-toothed aspect of the tops of the frames.
 

I know fairing of the hull is critical and the bottoms of the frames, adjacent to the keel rabbet is fairly true, but the tops look different from Toni's pictures and look like they're going to require some surgery to get right.
 
The next job is drawing the bearding line and then tapering the deadwood to accept the planks as they meet the sternpost.  I "temporarily installed the deadwood and Frames G and H."  Then I made a mark on the forward lower edge of the frames to define the bearding line.  Using a French curve, I drew the bearding line.
 




You might notice two lines in the picture above.  That's because the written instructions say to make the marks and draw the lines to define the curve from the forward bottom edges of frames G and H.  Here on MSW, Toni recommended making another mark at the bottom of Frame F, giving three points to define the curve.  I did it both ways to see what would happen and it didn't make a nickel's difference.
 
The deadwood has to be one plank thickness thinner at the sternpost and the keel than it is at the bearding line.  It's a very subtle change.  The deadwood is 0.127" thick.  That thickness needs to be reduced by the thickness of the planks: 0.035".  That means the final thickness will be 0.092" at the keel and sternpost, but will increase upward and forward to the original 0.127" thickness at the bearding line.
 
To make sure I didn't take off too much wood, I marked the plank thickness on the bottom and stern of the deadwood.

Then I started carving.  I've used only hand tools up to this point, but I did use my Dremel with a sanding burr to do this work.  I tried to get a good picture of the rabbet at the deadwood and the keel to show how this looks.


Once the carving is done, the deadwood, sternpost and L-shaped piece are glued to the board.

And then Frames F and G have to be installed.  The bottom of Frame G has to be tapered to conform with the bearding line.
 

That's it for today.  Pretty good progress, I think.
 
 
 
Dan
 

It took me a while, but I figured this thing out.  As usual, it required getting the right tool for the job.  I chose, in this case, bourbon.  This stuff has a thousand and one uses, I swear.

The fundamental problem, I figured out, was the placement of the counter.  The instructions do say "it sits on the curved part of the L-shaped piece already glued to the plan."  The thing I didn't understand that was that the bottom edge of it needed to conform with the bottom edge of the L-shaped piece.  I had the joint between the L-shaped piece and the deadwood running down the center of the edge of the counter.  That tiny difference, well, it made all the difference.
 
I cut out the counter.
 

You can see where the counter had been glued.
 
So then I reinstalled it, higher by a little bit, and, of course, that changed the whole geometry of the stern.  I did some cutting, shaping and carving and came up with this.
 


This is a difficult spot to take a picture of, but I think you can see the difference between before and after.  Now the pinstripe lays flat against the hull all the way around the stern.

 
Dan
 

I know it's been a while since I posted any updates.  I have made progress!
 
You can see here the second planking belt completed and the first layer of the wale installed.
 

 
It took me a couple of tries to get this right, but I was pretty happy with how it turned out.
 

 
Notice anything weird?  All that black staining?
 
The instructions recommend using an archival marker to stain the edges of the wale, so went over to Hobby Lobby and bought one.  I was really happy with how that went.  It looks like paint and is a lot less hassle.  I'd fitted the two pieces of the wale by wetting them, clamping them in place and letting them dry.  I removed them, used the marker and then let them dry for a day before reinstalling as you can see here.  Every time I touched the model, some of that black ink would come off on my hands.  I tried cleaning it off with a cottom swab and you can see the result below.  What a mess.
 

 
I'm so close to finishing this project off and the last thing I wanted was to ruin everything by bleeding black ink everywhere.  I decided to remove the wale and make a new one.  I used the old one as the template.
 

 

 

 
Even though I've removed the wale, there is still a little of that black ink on the frames.  I've been carefully removing it, but that looks to be a project that's going to take a while.
 
Anyone got any thoughts on where I went wrong? 
 
 
Dan  
 

I know it's been a while since I posted any updates.  I have made progress!
 
You can see here the second planking belt completed and the first layer of the wale installed.
 

 
It took me a couple of tries to get this right, but I was pretty happy with how it turned out.
 

 
Notice anything weird?  All that black staining?
 
The instructions recommend using an archival marker to stain the edges of the wale, so went over to Hobby Lobby and bought one.  I was really happy with how that went.  It looks like paint and is a lot less hassle.  I'd fitted the two pieces of the wale by wetting them, clamping them in place and letting them dry.  I removed them, used the marker and then let them dry for a day before reinstalling as you can see here.  Every time I touched the model, some of that black ink would come off on my hands.  I tried cleaning it off with a cottom swab and you can see the result below.  What a mess.
 

 
I'm so close to finishing this project off and the last thing I wanted was to ruin everything by bleeding black ink everywhere.  I decided to remove the wale and make a new one.  I used the old one as the template.
 

 

 

 
Even though I've removed the wale, there is still a little of that black ink on the frames.  I've been carefully removing it, but that looks to be a project that's going to take a while.
 
Anyone got any thoughts on where I went wrong? 
 
 
Dan  
 

I've been pokey about posting more updates here on MSW.  Work has consumed all my time over the past several weeks, so any time I get to spend at the bench is a real luxury.  I'm thankful every day for the work, but it is draining.
 
When last I posted, I'd just gotten the planking belts laid out.  It took some time to get that right, but it finally did come together.  I also took the opportunity to do more fairing.  It seems that's a never-quite-ending task, but a ncecessary one to avoid high and low spots.

Then I made my tic-strips for each of the frames.  Once I made these, I stored them in a little ziplock bag.  Don't lose them!  You'll need them again and again.
 
Per the instructions I used both methods to lay out the planking.  When I used the first method, I thought, "why in the world hadn't I thought of this before."  It made a lot of sense and was easy to do.
 

I didn't know it at this point, but, as clever as this method is, I got better results, faster, with the second method.  In any event, things went well.
 

Carving and sanding these very narrow planks was a little challenging.  I ruined a couple of them doing that, but eventually landed on this method.  Just clamp them in a self-locking pliers like this, with a piece of scrap stock on the bottom of them to keep them from moving around, and sand away.  I found I could keep them stable, see what I was doing and get a good result doing this.
 

Here's the first belt in place.



I think the first plank above the broad strake was too narrow.  I discovered that too late, so the next couple of planks are probably a little wider than they should be.  That's a live and learn, I think.  One great thing about this model is that ever run of planks is better than the one before it.  I've really noted an improvement in my skills as I've gone along, which is the purpose of a tutorial like this.
 
The stealer was next.  Toni says you'll be lucky to get this right in three tries.  I was.  I got it right in two. The first was a complete disaster and had to be removed...
 

With that gaping hole in my model -- and, you'll note -- the gap just where the stealer would have to be glued in, I plugged ahead.  Toni does say to install a block in between the frames, but what I failed to do was extend that block below the top edge of the plank.  I've got plenty of gluing surface where I don't need it in this picture, and none where I do.  Removing the first stealer to fix it allowed me to fix this whole issue.
 

And there it is.
 
Since this, I've laid out the second belt of planking and made my next set of tick strips.  Lots more planking to do.
 
 
Dan
 
 
 
 

Now on to the first run of planks.  I've gotten through about half of this process, but I'm struggling a little.
 
The initial instructions for laying out the planking belts are straightforward.  There are three belts of planks, the width of which are determined by the distance from the bottom of the main wale to the top of the broad strake.  Simple.  Take a piece of paper, mark that distance...
 

Measure...

 
...in this case 51mm.  And then divide by three.  That's 17mm.  Mark those belts on the dead flat.  Easy.
 
For the stem, it's the same process, although the geometry of the stem makes it a little different.  I drew a line from the top of the broad strake forward and a line from the bottom of the main wale forward onto the building board.  Then I measured that distance, divided by three and then marked those dimensions on the model.

In my case, the total distance from the bottom of the main wale to the top of the broad strake is 34 mm, which divides into three belts 11.3mm in width.
 
For the stern?  I'm befuddled.  As Toni says, "drawing out these belts is more complicated because the planks terminate on both the lower edge of the counter and the sternpost."  Okay.  Got it.  Complicated.
 
Then, in the next paragraph:  "The width of the lower planking belt at the sternpost is 4.5 (four regular planks and half a stealer) times the extreme width of 11" or 49.5".  In 1/48 scale, this is just over an inch.  Mark this at the sternpost."  Okay.  I can do that.  So that defines the border between the lower and middle belts.  Now I need to mark the border between the upper and middle belt.
 
"Measure inboard along the lower edge of the counter the width of four planks 0.75" (4 planks x 9" plank width / 48 scale)."  This had me baffled yesterday, but, as is my wont, I've let that thought marinate a little and here's what I came up with.  I've been thinking all along that the orientation of the planking belts is largely vertical, with some athwartships dimensionality to conform to the shape of the hull.  But in the case of marking out the border between the upper and middle planking belts, the orientation is largely athwartships.  So, "measure inboard along the lower edge of the counter" looks like this:

 
So ther planking belts will look something like this from the stern.  (I'm not taking any more pictures for now because there's a lot of adjustment that needs to be made to get these things right, as Toni points out in the instructions.)
 

 
 
Dan
 
 
 

Thank you, Gentlemen.  I'm glad you're enjoying the build log.  To the question about how I'm going to mount it, I would like to do it in the traditional half hull manner, on a wood backplate.  I'm concerned about the appearance of the top of the model though.  I don't want it to look like a construction site, which would happen if I left the tops of the frames exposed.  I'll need to do some thinking about this as the project progresses.
 
With the garboard strake in place, I moved on to the broad strake.  This plank took more work than the garboard strake.  I made three aft planks before getting one that I could install.  The fundamental problem is the amount of twist in these planks.  Of the three, the midships plank is the easiest to lay-out and install because there's very little twist in it.  Not only was it difficult to lay out the forward and aft planks with the Tamiya tape, but it was also hard to test fit them to make sure they would fit.
 
For the forward plank, Toni's instructions say, "mark the sternpost, dead flat frame and bow for the top of the strake and run a piece of tape to represent the top of the planking.  Again, be careful not to let the fore end of the planking run too high up the stem."  For the garboard -- and as I started laying out the broad strake -- I layed the tape out and then marked every frame, measuring all along, but with the instruction to not "let the fore end of the planking run too high up the stem," I came to the conclusions that this is a much less rigorous, analytical process than I had thought. It comes down to mark three spots and then eyeball it in.  Once I'd made that leap, layout got easier.
 
Now to that torsion issue, I've built with basswood before and it bends really nicely -- it even edge-bends nicely -- when simply wetted down with some warm water.  The heat of your hands working it is all that's needed, no fancy plank benders or anything.  After trying to horse the plank in place, I decided to just do that.  It's not mentioned anywhere in the instructions, but it certainly helped me.  I clamped the plank in place and let it dry.  When it was dry, I removed it, applied glue and set it in place without all kinds of force.  Toni does mention, earlier in the instructions, to be careful of putting dents in the wood.  That's easy to do and I did it.  I've since been working that little dent out by applying some water and letting the grain expand. You can see it in the second photo below.
 


The center plank, because there isn't much twist in it, is easy to lay out and install.  The after one, where there's the most twist, I found hard to lay out.  It took me three tries with the third time the charm.  Same procedure though.  Lay it out with the Tamiya tape and cut the plank.  Wet it to make it more pliable and clamp it in place.  Remove it when dry -- and here's the tricky part -- sand, fit, sand, fit, sand, fit, repeat as necessary until it's right.  In the end, I'm very happy with how that plank looks and the run of the broad strake, but it was more work than I anticipated.
 
You can see in this photo the amount of twist in that plank.

Here it is clamped in place.
 

And here's the finished result.
 



 
 
Dan
 
 

Well, two steps forward, one step back.
 
On Friday night, I got this from Kurt Van Dahm, President of our club, the Nautical Research and Model Ship Society of Chicago and NRG Director:  "A good indication that the Garboard plank is correct is to look at it at 90 deg to the keel piece and it should be a straight line fore to aft w/o the bow end rising.  It looks good from the head on view down the length."
 
So, I decided to check and, by that measure, my garboard strake needs work.

You can see that it does rise up at the forward end.
 
I've used Titebond on this model, which can be removed with isopropyl (rubbing) alcohol, which, around here anyway, is about as common in the grocery store as weapons-grade plutonium.  I had to come up with another way to correct this problem.
 
First thing I did was lay out that straight line with pinstriping tape.
 

Looking down at that line from as close to 90 degrees as I can get shows the problem at the bow.  I marked off the rise with a pencil and then, using a flexible ruler as a guide, cut off the part that needed to be removed.


You can see just a tiny bit of the strake still stuck to the keel, in the rabbet.  The rest of the strake came off easily because there really wasn't much adhesive holding it on.  At the extreme end, that wasn't the case.  Without isopropyl alcohol to soften this up, what could I do?  Normally, I would just use my heat gun on this, but this part of the model is, I thought, too delicate for that.  So I fired up my soldering iron to apply some focused heat to the area.  That did the trick.  Took the little piece of remaining strake right off.
 
I think it would be good to add a note about that "straight line when viewed 90 degrees to the keel" tip in the instructions.  Sure helped me see where my error was.  Toni does mention that her garboard strake ended about 0.90" from AF.  I was confused by that because mine ended farther forward than that.  Now I understand why.  After removing the rise in the strake, that 0.90" measurement makes a lot more sense.  You can see that mine now ends where it's supposed to.

 
 
Dan

I've installed the forward part of the garboard strake.  Really nothing hard about this at all.  I used the same process I did for the aft portion.
 
For clamping it down I used the same technique, but his time with the metal strip removed from an old windshield wiper blade.  That thing has found many uses in my shop.
 

Here you can see the complete garboard strake.

And here's a detail look at the bow.

And a look along the run of the plank.

All coming along nicely now.  I measured and marked out the broad strake last night.  I'll cut, carve and install at least part of it tonight.
 
 
 
Dan
 
 
 

The fairing of the stern was the most challenging part of the job so far.  There's some serious shaping that has to take place there.
 
And just when I thought I was done with all that, more opportunities popped up!
 
The first thing I did was plot out where the garboard strake would be.

That was easily done and then I laid a piece of pinstriping tape along those lines and checked them for fair.  I could see there were more high and low spots that needed attention.
 

So I spent more time fairing and getting that line where I wanted it.  This is a tedious process, but necessary, I think.
 
When I got it where I wanted it...

...then I laid out the garboard strake on some Tamiya tape.  I only had a roll of the 6 mm tape and this job really requires the 10 mm tape, but in these days of COVID-19, I didn't feel like running to the hobby shop (about a 30 minute drive, too) for that.  I ordered some online, but then just improvised a little.  I used two lengths of tape and just overlapped them a little.  You can kind of see that in the picture.  The important thing is what Toni points out.  You can see through the Tamiya tape, which allows you to see the marks made on the frames.
 

Here's the garboard strake with the tape removed.
 
 There was some final shaping to do on the strake and then gluing it in place.  That requires some thought too.  Getting the aft part of the strake to lay flat against the deadwood is a tricky clamping job unless you have some of those really long nosed clamps that Toni has.  I don't, so I improvised with a couple of pieces of scrap wood.  (Yes, that's walnut.  Very upscale scrap wood!)
 

And here's the final product.
 

The forward part of the strake went in tonight, much easier than the after part, I though.  I haven't uploaded those pictures yet, so stay tuned.
 
 
Dan
 
 
 
 

It took me a while, but I figured this thing out.  As usual, it required getting the right tool for the job.  I chose, in this case, bourbon.  This stuff has a thousand and one uses, I swear.

The fundamental problem, I figured out, was the placement of the counter.  The instructions do say "it sits on the curved part of the L-shaped piece already glued to the plan."  The thing I didn't understand that was that the bottom edge of it needed to conform with the bottom edge of the L-shaped piece.  I had the joint between the L-shaped piece and the deadwood running down the center of the edge of the counter.  That tiny difference, well, it made all the difference.
 
I cut out the counter.
 

You can see where the counter had been glued.
 
So then I reinstalled it, higher by a little bit, and, of course, that changed the whole geometry of the stern.  I did some cutting, shaping and carving and came up with this.
 


This is a difficult spot to take a picture of, but I think you can see the difference between before and after.  Now the pinstripe lays flat against the hull all the way around the stern.

 
Dan