Supplies of the Ship Modeler's Handbook are running out. Get your copy NOW before they are gone! Click on photo to order.
×
-
Posts
406 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Reputation Activity
-
hexnut reacted to SardonicMeow in Sultana by SardonicMeow - FINISHED - Model Shipways - Scale 1:64
Oh, right. I'm modeling the Sultana replica, which has a diesel engine. So I need a cutout in the rudder.
After looking at some reference pictures, I tried creating the cutout, which is roughly elliptical. It didn't look quite right.
Here is a screencap, cropped and flipped horizontally, from the YouTube video "Sultana Haul Out".
I see what's wrong now. On the replica, the rudder has been extended back to make up for area lost to the cutout. As a result, the back edge is nearly vertical. Also, another detail is that the bottom edge of the rudder is higher than the bottom of the keel. And a little bite will need to be taken out of the sternpost.
(Also interesting is that, in 2013 when this was recorded, the Sultana's hull was painted red below the water line. It was all white when launched. I don't know when the red color was added and whether or not it's still like that. I have noticed other changes in the paint job as well.)
Here is the revised rudder. The Schooner Sultana book says that the prop is 32 inches in diameter. At 1:64 scale, that's 12.7mm. I checked and the cutout is large enough.
-
hexnut reacted to SardonicMeow in Sultana by SardonicMeow - FINISHED - Model Shipways - Scale 1:64
Thanks for your comments. But I don't think I'll be quitting my day job just yet.
Working on the cap rail at the bow. First, a fit point spline to match the correct curve.
Cap rails will be 1/8" / 3.2mm wide. I use Sketch -> Offset with an offset of 1.6mm to create the inner edge.
The offset is repeated to create an edge 1.6mm in the opposite direction.
The original line is removed and the shape is closed.
And mirrored.
Here is the piece roughly in place. The actual piece will not be flat; it will slope down as it follows the top the bulwarks.
And here's a big picture of everything. There is one notable change. I decided not to include the gun stocks as part of the aft bulkhead pieces. I realized that I would have to plank around them, which seems like too much trouble.
And with that, I think I have designed all the pieces that I want. Now I need to arrange them for the laser cutter.
I'm still debating basswood vs. some other wood to use in the laser cutter.
-
hexnut reacted to SardonicMeow in Sultana by SardonicMeow - FINISHED - Model Shipways - Scale 1:64
Reference marks were added to the scribe lines for each bulkheads (in the same sketches where the fairing lines are drawn). These reference marks indicate the location of the wales and the bottom of the bulwarks on each bulkhead.
Next I turned to the end piece for the transom. After some careful measurement, I determined that the transom outline on the Model Shipways plans seemed to be properly sized. I scanned the image and brought it into Fusion 360. So far so good.
In this image the Model Shipways transom is on the left, and the Chapelle transom on the right. The general shapes are similar, but the MS transom windows are larger and spaced further apart. Also, on the MS transom the lines for the recessed portion of the transom are higher. (There are also some symmetry issues with the MS drawing.)
So what's correct? As I mentioned at the start of this build log, I will be using the Sultana replica as the standard. Fortunately, I found a good picture of the Sultana's transom at the website "829 Southdrive". Picture by the website author "Baydog".
From this picture, the windows should be fairly small, and the recess line is fairly low. That makes the Chapelle drawing the closer match.
Following the Chapelle transom and the reference photo, I came up with these two sketches for the two pieces.
Solid parts were created in the 3D environment to see how they will look. (The real parts will be curved.)
-
hexnut reacted to SardonicMeow in Sultana by SardonicMeow - FINISHED - Model Shipways - Scale 1:64
I've decided to go with the bulkheads at the bow that are perpendicular to the false keel. I have added some extra pieces at the bow. Blue lines are fairing lines that will be scribed onto the pieces
Shapes of the stem, keel, sternpost, and rudder were traced from the inboard profile image.
Bulkheads at the points where the deck level changes were doubled up so that there will be good surfaces where deck planks start and end.
There is also a cutout now, partially obscured in this picture, for the hatchway ladder that goes down into the hull.
And so here is what everything looks like at this point.
Still to be done:
design the transom end piece it might be nice to laser cut the cap rail at the bow add guide marks for the wales and any other useful reference marks
Then it's a matter of exporting each element as a DXF and arranging them for the laser cutter.
I need to decide soon whether I want to use basswood sheets or some harder wood. Because there are limitations on the width of hardwood sheets, that will affect how I can arrange the pieces for cutting.
-
hexnut reacted to SardonicMeow in Sultana by SardonicMeow - FINISHED - Model Shipways - Scale 1:64
I've been trying different ideas for how to deal with the bow.
The first option is fairly straightforward. There are holes in the bulkheads for the bowsprit. Blue lines are fairing lines that will be scribed on the parts.
Option two is a bit more radical. There are pieces at an angle somewhat analogous to cant frames. Horizontal pieces matching the curve of the bow will hold them in place.
It looks cool, but I don't know if there is any advantage to it.
-
hexnut reacted to SardonicMeow in Sultana by SardonicMeow - FINISHED - Model Shipways - Scale 1:64
Working on the transom this time. My goals include creating a strong surface that the end transom piece can be attached to. Also, I wanted to ensure that there is some open space behind the transom windows.
Here is in innermost piece.
And the next two pieces.
And some pictures of how the transom pieces fit together with the aft bulkhead pieces. Blue lines are the fairing lines that will be scribed on the pieces.
Next, as I have been gently reminded, I have to figure out how to deal with the bow of the ship.
-
hexnut reacted to SardonicMeow in Sultana by SardonicMeow - FINISHED - Model Shipways - Scale 1:64
Several bulkheads were added at the center of the ship. Because little to no fairing will be required, no fairing lines were identified for these bulkheads.
And here's another bulkhead in the aft part of the ship.
But maybe there is an opportunity here. If the bulkhead is positioned appropriately, then I can do this...
And that takes care of making the swivel gun stocks.
The same is done for the other locations with swivel gun stocks.
And just to get an idea of what the final product will look like, I thickened the bulkhead templates to the appropriate thickness.
This is what it looks like so far. I still need to work on the transom and bulkheads near the bow.
-
hexnut reacted to SardonicMeow in Sultana by SardonicMeow - FINISHED - Model Shipways - Scale 1:64
Before I add any more bulkheads, I think it's a good time to cut out the notches for the masts and bowsprit. The kit-supplied dowels are 6.4mm in diameter for the masts and 5.15mm in diameter for the bowsprit. Tapering will be required above the deck, but I'm happy to leave them at full diameter within the hull.
I edit the sketch for the false keel. Rectangles are added with a width equal to the diameter of the dowel, then rotated and moved in position to line up with the masts on the inboard profile image.
A similar procedure is followed for the foremast and bowsprit.
Finally, the Sketch -> Trim tool is used to get rid of the lines that aren't needed.
I hope that little pointy bit at the front won't break.
-
hexnut reacted to SardonicMeow in Sultana by SardonicMeow - FINISHED - Model Shipways - Scale 1:64
Finally I will start to find the shapes for some bulkheads. I know that I will want bulkheads at the three points where the deck level changes, so those seem like good ones to start with.
I start by making the inboard profile image visible, since it shows the internal structure. Via the construction menu, I create an offset plane at the point where the forecastle deck drops down to the main deck. It's 52.7 mm back from the forward perpendicular.
Next I make the hull and deck surfaces visible. I select the offset plane and go to Sketch -> Project/Include -> Intersect. As I move my mouse pointer over the surfaces, anywhere the offset plane intersects with a surface, the intersection curve displays as a red line. I'll click to select the first intersection curve.
And the one across the deck.
And finally the one on the other side of the hull.
When I click Ok the three curves are saved as a new sketch.
There is some overlap where the deck and hull lines meet. To edit the sketch any further, I have to break the link between the intersection curves and the surfaces. I select a curve, then right click and select Break Link. This is repeated for each curve. The curves change from purple to blue.
Now I go to Sketch -> Trim. When trim is active, segments of lines in a sketch that can be trimmed will turn red when the mouse pointer is over them. I trim off all the overhangs.
And I add a notch 25mm above the baseline.
The first bulkhead is complete. I can right click on the sketch, choose Export to DXF, and import the shape into laser cutter software.
Of course, I need to add a matching notch to the false keel.
I would also like to add fairing lines to each piece. The procedure is the same, but I don't need to include the intersection with the deck surface, and there is no notch.
For the other bulkheads at places where the deck level changes, I follow the same procedure. For the second bulkhead, the hull lines don't quite reach the deck curve. In this case, I first use Sketch -> Extend to extend the lines, then use Trim to trim any overhang.
I edit the false keel sketch and add notches at the appropriate locations for the three bulkheads I've created so far.
And here's a view of all the sketches defined in this session. All of these will be exported for use on the laser cutter.
-
hexnut reacted to SardonicMeow in Sultana by SardonicMeow - FINISHED - Model Shipways - Scale 1:64
The next thing I need to figure out is the exact placement of the decks and the deck camber. I bring up the inboard profile image. Starting a sketch in the centerline plane, I trace the lines along the underside of the planking on each deck. The lines for the two innermost decks (main deck? and quarter deck?) are very slightly curved. The other two are just straight lines. The sketch continues alone the rabbet and back to the start. I'll be using this sketch for the false keel. Notches for bulkheads will be added to it later.
The deck camber isn't obvious from the Chapelle plans. On the Model Shipways plans, there is a diagram showing an arc over a span of 72mm with the highest point of the arc at 2.5mm. I assume this is the camber at the widest part of the deck, but can be applied overall.
Applying those measurements, I create arcs on the 3D model passing through the start and end points of each deck.
Surfaces are lofted across the arcs. For the two larger deck sections, the line of the deck along the centerline is used as a rail, because it's curved. That gives those deck sections a very slight saddle shape.
(This picture makes it look like I'm creating a solar-powered ship. 🙂)
Here are all the surfaces to this point.
-
hexnut reacted to SardonicMeow in Sultana by SardonicMeow - FINISHED - Model Shipways - Scale 1:64
In order to establish a good ending shape for the hull, I added one more curve at the stern. This is a little guesswork since it isn't a line on the plans, but I think the shape is pretty close.
Now the lofting can begin. I click on "Create Form" to enter the sculpt environment. Then Create -> Loft.
When I select the start and end curves for the first loft, it looks like this.
From above, it's clear that the shape isn't right when there aren't any rails.
Once the rails are selected, the shape conforms to them.
The surface is constructed in sections by lofting between station lines.
Uh oh. The loft doesn't work back here.
My solution is to loft this area in two parts. First, I break the longer station line into two parts. The top part stops at the same height as where the smaller station line ends. The remaining half of the station line matches a line along the sternpost.
Then the two pieces are lofted separately.
There is a little gap between the pieces. The Modify -> Merge Edge operation is used to seal the gap.
I finish the lofting and create a mirror of the surface. It doesn't look too bad. The reflection in the aft area has a little wobble in it, showing the isn't quite smooth there, but I can deal with that later.
It's neat, but so what? How can I use this?
For my next trick, I need a volunteer (or several) from the audience to pick a number between 1 and 200.
-
hexnut reacted to SardonicMeow in Sultana by SardonicMeow - FINISHED - Model Shipways - Scale 1:64
The sketching of lines continues with finding intersection points and then sketching fit point splines through those points. Here are the intersection points for the two waterlines, with the waterline planes visible.
And then the splines. Drawing the lines is easy -- just a matter of connecting the dots with a little adjustment of the curves at the end.
The same procedure is followed for the load waterline. But wait... The intersection points don't seem to match up to the line on the plans. Is this an error in the plans?
No. This is because of how sketches work in Fusion 360. When you start a sketch, you choose the plane on which it will be drawn. Then Fusion 360 brings you to a view that is tangent to the drawing plane. Because the load waterline is tilted a little off horizontal, the view isn't directly down onto the plans. Instead, it's skewed a little, so the view doesn't match up. The load waterline drawn on the plans is a projection of the hull line down onto a horizontal surface, so to see it correctly, the view needs to be changed so that the viewport is looking directly down. See the view from directly overhead below.
Those of you with sharp eyes may have noticed that aft-most portions of the load waterline curve don't quite match the line on the plans. That is an issue with the plans, as the intersection point is correct in the sheer view. I think it's close enough not to matter much.
Do diagonals work like the load waterline? Are they projections down onto a horizontal surface? No, they really do get drawn directly on the tilted planes.
Here are all the lines at this point.
Now it's finally possible to create the hull surfaces.
-
hexnut reacted to SardonicMeow in Sultana by SardonicMeow - FINISHED - Model Shipways - Scale 1:64
Now I'll create sketches of the various hull curves.
(In the 3D/CAD forum, there is a thread where I worked through this method. You can check it out if you're interested in more details about the procedure.)
For the topmost line, I will create a curve following one of the bulwark lines on the plan. To ensure correct placement, I create a construction point at the tip of the bow, which will be used as a starting point for the curve. A fit point spline is created in a horizontal plane following the curve as viewed from above.
Then the points on the spline are adjusted up or down to fit the curve as viewed from the side and front.
In the picture below, the curve is viewed from the front and back showing how it follows the plan.
Next is a sketch for the rabbet line. It is composed of several lines and curves. The sketch is drawn in the false keel thickness offset plane. The same starting point at the bow is used to start the bow curve, meaning that the bulwarks curve and bow curve intersect at that point.
Here are the two sketches so far.
Now I select the construction plane for station 1, then go to Sketch -> Project/Include -> Intersect and click on the existing lines to find the points where they intersect with the plane. This is repeated for each station plane. The intersection points are displayed as purple circles.
Using the intersection points as start and end points, a fit point spline is sketched for each station following the curves on the body plan.
Why all the intersection points? Later on, I'll be using the loft and rails feature in the Fusion 360 sculpt environment. Loft creates a surface between two or more curves (profiles). Rails can be used to adjust the flow of the loft. However, all rails used in a loft must intersect all profiles. To make sure all the curves intersect as needed, I find the intersection points first, and draw fit point splines using those intersection points.
Next time, sketching continues.
-
hexnut reacted to SardonicMeow in Sultana by SardonicMeow - FINISHED - Model Shipways - Scale 1:64
Step one is to bring the plans into Fusion 360 as canvas objects. The plans are checked to make sure that all lines are perfectly horizontal / vertical, and that lines in one view match up to the corresponding lines in a different view. The images have been scaled in the 3D environment to match the scale of the model (1:64 or 1 foot = 3/16"). The 3D origin is at the intersection of the baseline, the centerline, and the forward perpendicular.
A number of construction planes are defined. Here are the station planes.
And the two water lines plus the load water line.
Planes for the three diagonals are also defined.
And canvas objects for the diagonals are added to the environment.
A final, and very important, construction plane is one which defines the thickness of the false keel. I plan to use 1/8" thick wood for the false keel and bulkheads. Converting to metric, that's 3.2mm. But because I am only building a half hull now, which will be mirrored later, I will set the false keel offset plane to be 1.6mm from the centerline.
With the reference images imported and the construction planes defined, the environment is ready for the hull modeling to start.
-
hexnut reacted to SardonicMeow in Sultana by SardonicMeow - FINISHED - Model Shipways - Scale 1:64
My plan, which I hope is not too ambitious, is to make a plank on bulkhead hull. I have access to a local makerspace with a laser cutter, so I intend to laser cut the pieces. I'd like to develop a workflow of going from plans to parts that I can apply to future projects.
Let's look at the plans of the Sultana.
Follow this link to see the original plans on the National Maritime Museum website. I suspect most visitors to MSW are familiar with the circumstances of the Royal Navy acquiring and recording the lines of the Sultana.
Who exactly did the work of recording the plans, at Mr Randall's dock in 1768? Was it this guy whose name is in the corner? Adam Hayes?
You probably know how the plans were cleaned up and recorded by Howard Chapelle in 1935. The Chapelle plans are reproduced on the end papers of the Schooner Sultana book.
In white on orange... Thanks guys.
Scan, invert colors, levels, convert to grayscale, more levels, crop into separate files.
That's better.
What stands out about the plans is how few station lines there are. Just nine. Was Mr. Hayes in a rush to meet his mates at the pub that day?
Often, the plans of a larger ship will have 20 or more stations, and a modeler can just choose all or some, make bulkheads directly from those lines, and be done with it. But nine isn't enough. Based on my one and only plank on bulkhead experience, I want more bulkheads. I want lots of bulkheads.
It's time to find my bulkhead lines. It's time to go to the drawing board start up the CAD software.
-
hexnut reacted to SardonicMeow in Sultana by SardonicMeow - FINISHED - Model Shipways - Scale 1:64
Welcome to my Sultana build log.
I plan for my Sultana to deviate from the kit in two significant ways.
First, I will be modeling the 2001 Sultana replica, rather than the 1767 original. In addition to pictures taken by myself and others, I'll be using the book Schooner Sultana: Building a Chesapeake Legacy by Drew McMullen with photos by Lucian Niemeyer.
The book covers the construction of the 2001 ship with lots of descriptions and photographs. Best of all, there is an appendix with measurements of many of the main components.
The second significant deviation is this.
-
hexnut reacted to Sundt in Colin Archer no.414 By Sundt - Billing Boats - RADIO - polystyrene hull
Some more gluing tomorrow 🙂
-
hexnut got a reaction from Canute in WRITER’S BOAT MODELS
Joseph Conrad and the Otago, Allen Villiers and the Joseph Conrad?
-
hexnut got a reaction from thibaultron in WRITER’S BOAT MODELS
Joseph Conrad and the Otago, Allen Villiers and the Joseph Conrad?
-
hexnut got a reaction from mtaylor in WRITER’S BOAT MODELS
Joseph Conrad and the Otago, Allen Villiers and the Joseph Conrad?
-
hexnut reacted to Mirabell61 in HJEJLEN by Mirabell61 - FINISHED - scale 1:50 - RESTORATION - Danish live museum vintage paddle steamer restored by Nils Langemann
Hi Druxey,
thank you for your word
jes, thats true and whenever I saw an old unbuilt kit of this one being offered (very rarely) the prices were so extraordinary high, but my mind still went pregnant with this thought (someday the time may come ! )
Cheers, Nils
wish my hand would be more steady for the paint job on appr. 50 passengers...., but the hairstyles, shoes and other details will get touch-ups
-
hexnut reacted to Mirabell61 in HJEJLEN by Mirabell61 - FINISHED - scale 1:50 - RESTORATION - Danish live museum vintage paddle steamer restored by Nils Langemann
Welcome to this topic Mark and Lars/Peter, and B.E.
and many thanks for your kind comments.
Also thanks to the "likes"
For this kit I`m missing the 2 bullseyes for sidewise in the front section of the hull, and the golden plover figurehead for the upper bow post. Alternative parts are now ordered. The stand looks quite flimsy, so I decided to make pedestals from brass / wooden candle holders with a shaped outcuts for the keel to fit into. Small M3 screws hold these pedestals firmly to the keel. they will fit directly to the baseplate of the glass casing.
The two ( meanwhile come loose) paddle wheels were glued to the hull. Now both paddle wheels have become an brass axis between outside spashguards segments and the hull. I am intending to place crew and passengers on board, like I did wth the Bohuslän steamer. Its not easy to find the right scale figures, and there are so many non occupied benches. I placed the benches on the upper aft deck, turned around, now back to back 180°, so that the passengers will face the water side of the rivers and lakes for a better view. The roof of the front well also requires some additional holding posts, as the current ones are quite flimsy, and therefore the roof quite instable
Also the ships boat is not in correct scale, so there will be an alternative boat fitted under the davits....
Nils
this is the "old" stand
the wood / brass new pedestals
New pedestals fitted to the keel (they had to be low in hight, due to the limited glass case hight )
the new brass axis for the paddle wheels, also to make them turnable
crew and passenger figures, prior to painting job
-
hexnut reacted to Mirabell61 in HJEJLEN by Mirabell61 - FINISHED - scale 1:50 - RESTORATION - Danish live museum vintage paddle steamer restored by Nils Langemann
Hi there,
all you steam-paddle-boat lovers
since I was a teen I had an eye on this lovely boat. It is the long time already out of production vintage Billing Boats kit named "HJEJLEN" Golden Plover, German : Goldregenpfeifer.
A few days ago I could hardly believe my luck in finding this offered complete kit-built boat, on Ebay, a bit damaged, together with a suit-taylored glass case, so I invested a drive to the seller in the region of Bremen area, and picked it up.
After thorough inspection back home I determined the minimum of parts and components required to restore and overhaul the charming old lady. I shall show the sequences of recovery and restoration in the next weeks to come, here in this tread.
As this will be no complete new build, but certainly worth an shorter thread on this forum, as I`m sure that there is interest for this model by the one or other fellow member.
Credit goes to the late father of the seller who built this steamer many years ago. It is known to be the oldest live steam, still cruising boat with passengers in the waters of Silkeborg in Denmark
Nils
name giver birdie, Hjejlen, Golden plover, Goldregenpfeifer
-
hexnut reacted to LE CONSUL in WRITER’S BOAT MODELS
For years, I have sailed for my pleasure around the world, on many boats. And since I stopped my professional activity, I dedicate myself to the Sea. It goes through collections of boats and by reading writers of the Sea. I amassed, a large number of metal toy boats from the beginning of the last century and my new hobby is to build writer’s boat models.
The difficulty does not lie only in the construction, but first in the search of writers who have owned boats and even in the availability of their plans: kits exist for some, plans are available for others in French, English or American museums and, sometimes, you have to follow a breadcrumb trail to obtain the hull plans.
This passion led me to build 1/30th scale models, all different in their size, style or origin:
- PILAR to Ernest Hemingway
- SAINT-MICHEL III to Jules Verne
- ALTAÏR to Henry de Monfreid (under construction)
YAO to Eric Orsena (also in progress)
OSTROGOTH to Georges Simenon
The following projects are envisaged if hull plans (or kits) exist:
- CASCO from Robert Louis Stevenson
- SNARK to Jack London
- WESTERN FLYER to John Steinbeck
- RING DOVE from William Faulkner
- BEL AMI to Guy de Maupassant
- AMPHITRITE to J.K. ROWLING (Harry Potter)
Among these projects, there is one, very difficult and with a very poor documentation: it is the schooner EMMA to Alexandre Dumas (the Three Musketeers). Unfortunately, only two or three drawings are available, unreliable and insufficient to build a model. To get the hull plans, three "tracks" opened to me when I started my research.
- The first, by the shipyard that built the boat in Liverpool, UK. We are fortunate to have in our family an admiral of the Navy; he began research in the Admiralty and in British museums; but the research has yet been unsuccessful.
- The second by the silver prints of Gustave Le Gray, one of the first photographers, a friend of Dumas' time, but without having been able to discover Emma so far in his photos.
- The third by the books of Dumas himself. In "Viva Garibaldi", he delivers the origin of his Emma: she was built for the Duke of Gramont, his friend and from whom he had acquired her. I looked to see if I could locate his descendants.
Today, I don't have a solution.
My request is simple: among the readers of this blog, does anyone know that there are, about the above writers' boats, kits or plans (CASCO, SNARK, WESTERN FLYER, RING DOVE, BEL AMI, AMPHITRITE and EMMA). In addition, if a reader gave me information about a boat outside the list above, I would be grateful.
So here is my first request. Do any kits exist or, if not, could someone send me the plans for these boats.
-
hexnut reacted to Old Grunt Marine in Fair American - Lauck Street Shipyard
Hi, Steve,
I built this model (#3) when Bob first released it. I can't give you any tips because I don't remember much, but a photo is attached. Authentic or not, accurate or not, I can says it's beautiful, and one of my two favorites. I wasn't a member then so there is no build log.
Miles