Wawona59 Posted March 23 Share #31 Posted March 23 At first glance I thought this kit was great as it is designed to be built as an admiralty style model, kind of like the Model Shipways Confederacy. Upon closer examination, I've changed my first impression of this kit. This kit is marketed to an advanced ship modeler but I think it falls short. An advanced modeler would not make but jointed carlings for the exposed gun deck framing. They also would not be happy with the inaccurate fittings and oversized belaying pins. The stern galleries would probably be replaced, etc. etc. Upon completion, this would result in a very nice "decorator model" that the builder could be proud of. The market that might be interested in this kit would be a modeler with few kits under their belt who is newly retired and looking for a challenge in their retirement years. If I were going to plunk down $1,700.00 for a ship model (unlikely) there are other models on the market more deserving of my $$. Here's a few: Syren Winchelsea, Bluejacket Wyoming, Vanguard Indefatigable. This model does not appeal to me. I'm sure Occre will sell a few though. allanyed and mtaylor 2 Quote Wawona 59 John Next Project: Gifts for friends: 18th Century Pinnace, Kayak 17, Kayak 21 Indefinite Hold for the future: 1/96 Flying Fish, Model Shipways Wish list for "Seattle Connection" builds: 1/96 Lumber Schooner Wawona, 1/32 Hydroplane Slo-Mo-Shun IV, 1/96 Arthur Foss tug, 1/64 Duwamish cedar dugout canoe, 1/96 Downeaster "St. Paul" Selected Previous Completed Builds: Revell - 1/96 Thermopylae; Revell - 1/96 Cutty Sark, Revell - 1/96 Constitution, Aurora - Whaling Bark Wanderer, Model Shipways - 1/96 Phantom, AL - 1805 Pilot Boat Swift, Midwest - Chesapeake Bay Flattie, Monitor and Merrimac, Model Trailways - Doctor's Buggy Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
allanyed Posted March 23 Share #32 Posted March 23 3 hours ago, Wawona59 said: They also would not be happy with the inaccurate fittings and oversized belaying pins. Seems they follow a theme in this regard. The other offerings you mention have shown these problems are not without solutions. Allan mtaylor 1 Quote PLEASE take 30 SECONDS and sign up for the epic Nelson/Trafalgar project if you would like to see it made into a TV series. Click on http://trafalgar.tv There is no cost other than the 30 seconds of your time. THANK YOU Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ouija2006 Posted March 23 Share #33 Posted March 23 This model is good enough to be honored by the National Museum of the Royal Navy so I am assuming that it cannot be that bad. I received this announcement in an email from OcCre on March 7th. The link can be found below: OcCre HMS Victory md1400cs, rmccook and mtaylor 3 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
JMPAQ Posted August 27 Share #34 Posted August 27 Je constate à la lecture de tous vos échanges que vous êtes tous des modélistes performants et que vous regardez les autres avec un peu de dédain ! certes ce kit de OCCRE n’est peut être pas une vérité historique et peut présenter de nombreuses approximations ou défauts mais il n’en reste pas moins que ce peut être une bonne entrée dans le monde de la maquette et peut apporter de grandes satisfactions à celui qui veut réaliser une maquette de belle taille et un vaisseau renommé ; quitte à ce qu’il apporte les modifications ou précisions qu’il aura envie à partir des nombreuses documentations sur ce navire rmccook and MCan 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.