Craigie65
-
Posts
467 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Gallery
Events
Everything posted by Craigie65
-
DB789 Originally I tried to plank as you have shown the third plank, but it was just not sitting right for me at the cross over from where it changes from vertical to almost horizontal to meet the counter. -
Hi Jonathan, Whilst I cannot part with my secret for wealth and happiness, here are my steps for getting that pesky plank on mine. I had two planks below the bulwark before turning the next to meet the stern. The first plank was full like you have, the second covered the triangular shape. The third plank is tricky, as you have to twist it to meet the counter. Where the third plank wants to ride up over the second, I chose to twist the plank so that it lay on top of the edge of the second plank rather than meeting it at an angle. I use CA glue to help me here. I think I had to sand a little at the point where the third plank twists to help it sit better. I was then able to sand the contour, using the trick of sawdust and glue to fill any small gaps. The starboard side was the best. Looking at the port I had to shape a hook into the second plank to let the third rest better. You can just about see that in the picture below. After that the remaining planks sat fine with edge bevelling and a bit of edge bending (steam the rear if you are doing this). Once all your second planking is done a bit of gentle sanding will bring it all together.
-
Dropped you a PM with the method I followed
-
That looks really good , Glomar! Brilliant to see you have persevered and won the battle of the first planking. It does get easier as you have something to guide you and, of course, you learn so much from the first. Looking forward to seeing the second planking.
-
Hi Andrew, So thick that it really looked like the timberheads!
- 206 replies
-
- 1
-
-
- Vanguard Models
- Brixham trawler
- (and 2 more)
-
Try Cornwall Model Boat CMB
-
I’m sure Andrew will respond, but my guess is styrene strips or spare square stock were added before spraying and removed when ready for the kit timberheads.
- 206 replies
-
- 2
-
-
- Vanguard Models
- Brixham trawler
- (and 2 more)
-
Andrew, Apart from being obviously longer, the stern goes a bit flatter before hitting the stern post. You can see I have not planked right to the end. Otherwise I think the second planking will be roughly the same as Nisha.
-
Time to start the second planking. Decided to fit the first plank without any tapering as it covers the lower part of the inner bulwark. Not sure what’s going on here but the plank came up a bit short. I will have to add a small triangular plank. I do not think that will be an issue as the wale covers this piece. Same on both sides - I offered up an uncut plank and they are too short, but only for this one plank. I then used a bit of tape to line off the first band of the hull to be four planks wide amidship. I then took the measurement at each frame and worked out the taper. Not too much of a taper at the bow or stern.
-
I use a chisel blade which is fine enough to get under the nail head. Whilst I have never had a blade break I do wear safety glasses.
-
Glomar, Looking much better. You should be able to lever the nails out. Take care doing that. Can you test whether part 58 will fit correctly on the stem? I cannot quite see from the final photo but plank number 2 looks to be touching the front of the stem. You might get away with carving it back to fit 58.
-
@starlight Here is my build of Erycina. The garboard plank sits well and the additional pieces form a nice rabbet for the second planking. All down to the great design from Chris Watton.
-
Glomar, This plank is looking much better. Is there any give in the bulwarks at frames 2 and 3? If so they may not be flat against the frame causing the plank to look a touch low. If they are I think Starlight is right and you will have to blend a little once the planking is finished. I too would remove these pins now - it is a pain to get them off once you have added the next plank. I found the rear a bit tricky too given the sheer of the stern. You will have to use a bit of filler to blend the plank once you have finished planking the hull. Time for plank number 2! @starlight I would normally agree, but the design of this kit does not need a rabbet (rebate) for the first planking. I found both Nisha and Erycina can have the first plank added without it. The lines allow the garboard plank to sit well. There are additional parts which form the rabbet for the second planking.
-
Glomar, That is looking much better. Well done for taking the plunge to restart your planking, it will pay off in the long run. Good idea adding that shim for the front of the bulwarks. What I was trying to convey is the counter pieces 21 to 24 are frames that need to be faired as the counter is curved across the the beam of the boat. If you took a plank and laid it across the counter frames you would see it only touches this highest edges of these frames. You can see from this photo of Erycina’s counter how much of a curve is in this piece. It looks as if the counter is conforming to the curve of the stern. If it is secure I would be tempted to leave it. Good advice from @Andyrew each plank is a mini project.
-
So on to the counter and outer bulwarks. I deviated slightly from the build sequence and attached the keel, stem and stern outer pieces first. In particular the the stern piece as I found it fiddlier on my Nisha where I fitted the counter first and then the outer stern piece. At this point Erycina is going through her punk phase. I decided to presoak the outer counter - it makes glueing easier. Finally I added the outer bulwarks - the hole on the front port outer bulwark does not seem to align very well with the inner. Looks as if I will need to drill this later. The starboard side has the bowsprit hole again a bit out of alignment but a bit of filing will sort that. No big deal really, just thought worth mentioning in case you come across this.
-
I agree with @mtaylor that a pick and mix approach is sometimes the best.
-
Happy to input if helpful. Unfortunately I did not keep a build log. @AJohnson has a very good log of his build of Nisha, in particular the bulwarks and first planking. I am sure we will all help as much as we can.
-
Hi Glomar, Don’t be disheartened, we all sometimes feel out of our depth. Well maybe not Chuck Look at @Dave_E build of Lady Nelson. He had similar planking issues and made the brave decision to remove his first attempt. He is now going great guns. I believe Isopropyl alcohol is the preferred method on MSW. Personally I have never had to use it - I have removed the offending planks with warm water as the glue had not fully cured. The difference in height on the planks could be just the thickness of each. As good as the quality of the materials Vanguard use there is always some variation. I have just had a similar problem on my current build but managed to sand it out. If not then it could be a high or low spot on the frame - a bit more sanding if a high spot or a shim if low will sort that out.
-
If part 58 does not fit, then as painful as it maybe, then yes I would. Otherwise I think your second planking will be a bit of a struggle. You will not be the first to strip off bulwarks. I have often removed offending planks. For my build of Erycina, I drew in the position of the equivalent of part 58. I used this as a guide to make sure my first planking did not encroach. You can see the pencil line.
-
Productive Easter weekend. First planking on, needs a bit of sanding, but reasonably happy with this. I did crowd the planks at the counter. For my next model I will split the hull into bands to give me a better idea of the run of the planks.
-
Looking at the front edge of your bulwark and planks. They look to be too far forward. Part 58 needs to fit on the stem to act as a rebate for your second planking. From the last photo it does not look as if they will fit. Step 72 has a good photo of how the front edge of your first planking should sit.
-
Hi, A couple of things come to mind, which may help you. First is edge bending - have a look for Chuck’s video of this in the planking techniques. Second is bevel the top edge of your planks. As planks are covering a curve they create a gap if the back edge is not bevelled. Hope that helps
-
Amati have a range of crew in various sizes. 25mm is the close to 1/64, depending on the original height of the crew member.
-
Hey we all have our moments. The main thing is you went the extra mile and fixed the problem.
-
On Nisha I did not have that problem, not sure why! I did split one of the bulwarks - let’s keep that between us The counter was pre soaked twice. The first time I did not clamp one of the rear corners properly and induced a bit of a wave. Nailed it on the second attempt.
Our Emblem ®
