Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hi everyone, I started scratch build of a Columbus Santa Maria according to an Anatomy of the ship book by Xavier Pastor. It seamed to me it would not be a too difficult job since I have a book and just need to follow it, but there was equally time spent on thinking of how to build something or deciding in what way to build since plans have decent amount of inaccuracies and lack of details. IMG_20201228_140506.thumb.jpg.afa9f79b2cdab69e61152a8d7037073c.jpgIMG_20201227_173114.thumb.jpg.82146a31d8a33e9451e8bf7b641ea01d.jpg

IMG_20210115_161824.jpg

IMG_20210112_123049.jpg

IMG_20210110_155501.jpg

IMG_20210106_175420.jpg

IMG_20210106_175343.jpg

IMG_20210103_122746.jpg

IMG_20201230_142736.jpg

IMG_20201230_121448.jpg

IMG_20201226_113925.jpg

IMG_20201226_113919.jpg

IMG_20210129_143157.jpg

IMG_20210125_125029.jpg

IMG_20210125_125016.jpg

IMG_20210123_122630.jpg

IMG_20210123_122617.jpg

IMG_20210131_121308.jpg

IMG-20210129-WA0003.jpeg

IMG_20210213_171727.jpg

IMG_20210213_162343.jpg

IMG_20210212_234151.jpg

IMG_20210208_200952.jpg

IMG_20210208_200946.jpg

IMG_20210206_153718.jpg

IMG-20210205-WA0011.jpeg

IMG-20210205-WA0009.jpeg

IMG-20210205-WA0007.jpeg

IMG-20210205-WA0005.jpeg

IMG_20210214_151343_1.jpg

Posted

Gusar,

 

    Please define 'inaccuracies'.  Since there is no record of the details of the Santa Maria, there is alot of leeway in the building process. 

 

    The build looks good so far.  What other builds have you done?

Chuck Seiler
San Diego Ship Modelers Guild
Nautical Research Guild

 
Current Build:: Colonial Schooner SULTANA (scratch from Model Expo Plans), Hanseatic Cog Wutender Hund, Pinas Cross Section
Completed:  Missouri Riverboat FAR WEST (1876) Scratch, 1776 Gunboat PHILADELPHIA (Scratch), John Smith Shallop

Posted

Hi Chuck,

I will list some of inaccuracies or mistakes I found. 20231006_132728.thumb.jpg.62bc97aa2673a2712d1e1bbaf067c7d8.jpg

When you compare body plan with sheer and half-breadth plan and measure everything this what you get. This is in milimeters. I took that sheer and half-breadth plan are more accurate.

 

Screenshot2023-10-06134233.png.4826ac5f81048c787b898f0bc0872504.pngScreenshot2023-10-06134309.png.100719bda6efca139b9f44e20af9f597.png

One ladder not two.

 

20231006_133950.thumb.jpg.8ee8d977444d83a5b4c166f8a0eaabe9.jpg

Screenshot2023-10-06134607.png.89e07917b1f6eb36e693ce6b615466ad.png

 

Had to add the this for main yard hoisting.

 

Screenshot2023-10-06134755.png.d970ea68fb9ab614b121faf331d634f7.png

Cleats are on wrong places, found out later when started putting the shrouds

 

 

 

Screenshot2023-10-06135137.png.20d26d765448f9eddd7ba2834cca5f57.png

 

Absolutely no cleats for fastening all the ropes, also lack of better explanation of how forecastle is constructed.

 

Screenshot2023-10-06134535.png.63ffb7cf296173fdf43612d77718999e.pngScreenshot2023-10-06134700.png.7da8a0dd10885714971d3650f4f8bcd9.pngTwo different fore stay versionsScreenshot2023-10-06134642.png.6abe9b88d4a39d9aa53eed056aac3d69.png

 

Spritsail is too large, spritsail on the previous picture is better

 

Screenshot2023-10-06184124.png.67c42c6ed1d1dc96f9c790564f735e85.png

This framing is not in an alignment with other plans, so much correction is need if you want to make admiralty model or just to match visible frames with other plans.

There are some other mistakes I can't remember now, for example anchor is too big for the scale so adjustments are needed. Much care is to be taken studying plans before starting the build. I don't have so much experience so i didn't see all of this in advance. 

Posted
On 10/5/2023 at 7:21 PM, Chuck Seiler said:

Gusar,

 

    Please define 'inaccuracies'.  Since there is no record of the details of the Santa Maria, there is alot of leeway in the building process. 

 

    The build looks good so far.  What other builds have you done?

I did two Adriatic Trabaccolo, and one fishing boat.

Posted

That's  some very nice work, I only wish.

    :cheers:

Start so you can Finish !!

Finished:         The Sea of Galilee Boat-Scott Miller-1:20 ,   Amati } Hannah Ship in a Bottle:Santa Maria : LA  Pinta : La Nana : The Mayflower : Viking Ship Drakkar  The King Of the Mississippi  Artesania Latina  1:80 

 

 Current Build: Royal Yacht, Duchess of Kingston-Vanguard Models :)

Posted (edited)
6 hours ago, Gusar said:

Much care is to be taken studying plans before starting the build. I don't have so much experience so i didn't see all of this in advance. 

I see, the inaccuracies are within the plan itself.

 

Very true.  It is very frustrating when you have what appears to be a good set of plans, but AFTER you start working on it you find the various parts of the plan are not reconciled with each other.  I guess learning that, and learning what things you need to verify early on are part of the 'gaining experience' process.

 

Looking good so far.

Edited by Chuck Seiler
mis spelling

Chuck Seiler
San Diego Ship Modelers Guild
Nautical Research Guild

 
Current Build:: Colonial Schooner SULTANA (scratch from Model Expo Plans), Hanseatic Cog Wutender Hund, Pinas Cross Section
Completed:  Missouri Riverboat FAR WEST (1876) Scratch, 1776 Gunboat PHILADELPHIA (Scratch), John Smith Shallop

Posted

Very impressive work. I've tried a couple of models built on a plug and always found difficulty in getting the two halves exactly the same. You seem to have succeeded admirably. And you've done a superb job on the (difficult) rounded stern. Very precise work.

 

Steven

Posted (edited)
10 hours ago, Louie da fly said:

Very impressive work. I've tried a couple of models built on a plug and always found difficulty in getting the two halves exactly the same. You seem to have succeeded admirably. And you've done a superb job on the (difficult) rounded stern. Very precise work.

 

Steven

Two halves were nothing comparing to rounded stern :) it could have been better, but next time it will be.

Thank you all for kind words here is continuation of the work.

 

20211220_132524.thumb.jpg.b5b43291ceabf765204d9aa16c81e33e.jpg20211220_132512.thumb.jpg.28d1af02cdf3e6c3edff55d02b61963a.jpg20220102_184027.thumb.jpg.de02e3d5869b877d17a956c41e768373.jpg20220102_184020.thumb.jpg.74fd7401fb46cb0ed3420d668cce4fd9.jpg20220102_184557.thumb.jpg.492ec58c21a922d7a045853da081ea10.jpg20220102_184605.thumb.jpg.329c9bec3d438a56cb2d6d0c071dd0cd.jpg

20220117_114959.thumb.jpg.c059a9de1b8d1bbb955cdff1c5cfb1df.jpg20220117_115002.thumb.jpg.f2883d85a2cc0ef9f59ca7c4d11f3738.jpg20220118_141352.thumb.jpg.2c8cd9d8f48ddefdabe4cb89cc78cb81.jpg20220117_114948.thumb.jpg.8b18833d98d68c77afebec70211cde50.jpg20220117_145029.thumb.jpg.924a3f3048d15447ca826420fed5a9a2.jpg20220117_145231.thumb.jpg.0ba19ef0dd5acce4fd535a17a1eb0f97.jpg20220118_141336.thumb.jpg.9f5d391cb5fe2118f58cbdadd65d800e.jpg20220120_153202.thumb.jpg.c3ab1cdf8dc83671c99de840214cd7b0.jpg20220120_153240.thumb.jpg.f51fb026a0d1fbebb99a23f6c527c052.jpg20220120_153251.thumb.jpg.6d5b928fcc5addb7615b3753289f2f76.jpg20220123_114520.thumb.jpg.dca0d4293b4fdc09752dbcae2d36640d.jpg20220123_114529.thumb.jpg.580b5f02db779f4763d3b1b33c237d56.jpg20220123_114554.thumb.jpg.0ea4311daa91663107e991b63454b883.jpg20220124_131947.thumb.jpg.7249b3ac25374f3a2df5c88048409344.jpg20220124_132003.thumb.jpg.86f29094eda25ce7501301c81202cd62.jpg

 

Edited by Gusar
Posted

I’ve never had much interest in the Columbus ships; probably a result of having seen too many really bad replicas and models.  You, however, have produced a stunning model that in my opinion nicely captures the essence of what a late Fifteenth Century Nao might have looked like.

 

Your hull construction technique is unique and innovative

 

Well done!

 

Roger

Posted

Very nice.  What wood are you using for planking and doors, etc?

Chuck Seiler
San Diego Ship Modelers Guild
Nautical Research Guild

 
Current Build:: Colonial Schooner SULTANA (scratch from Model Expo Plans), Hanseatic Cog Wutender Hund, Pinas Cross Section
Completed:  Missouri Riverboat FAR WEST (1876) Scratch, 1776 Gunboat PHILADELPHIA (Scratch), John Smith Shallop

Posted
16 hours ago, Roger Pellett said:

I’ve never had much interest in the Columbus ships; probably a result of having seen too many really bad replicas and models.  You, however, have produced a stunning model that in my opinion nicely captures the essence of what a late Fifteenth Century Nao might have looked like.

 

Your hull construction technique is unique and innovative

 

Well done!

 

Roger

Hi Roger,

I was really thinking a lot about how to capture this essence as you said. Looking at many contemporary pictures to try decide which colour to go for. The wood I use is pear stained with two colours dark walnut and redish walnut. First I would put redish one and then quickly applied dark one so wood can soak bit of both. That is why colour is not uniform you will see more on later pictures. 

Hull construction method I took from russian master Michael Bezverhny.

 

 

Posted (edited)

Forecastle I did I think two or three times. Since there was no pictures in the plans of how this was made I did it by the eye.

 

20220201_140826.thumb.jpg.3ea6f3f42f38b7cda057eb7c2a0296e5.jpg20220201_140838.thumb.jpg.32c3424a5ae683247817c79e70313ef0.jpg20220201_152401.thumb.jpg.51a603a9e2ed412023acd8822cf36503.jpg20220207_112323.thumb.jpg.c8032b057e4c0d50cd5eb9413fcb47a7.jpg20220201_152354.thumb.jpg.350bfceb3b3a021db787bc44f3872f28.jpgf

20220209_154123.thumb.jpg.9495672bdcb2062ed3b72270e0842214.jpg

This middle horizontal beam is placed to get the convex shape of the clinker planking.20220209_154136.thumb.jpg.f81e02efdc860981e48b1a4722b66a61.jpg20220210_134503.thumb.jpg.09a2812d307c8acbc3f16370478c631c.jpg20220210_134457.thumb.jpg.338a5f3552d3b981f69bf1dc1c18c355.jpg20220210_134451.thumb.jpg.bed95b5cd68c542b8e9a306140d45a3a.jpg

 

20220215_134105.thumb.jpg.68599f77a5858b8dca1aa58873649cb8.jpg20220215_134112.thumb.jpg.bbd6fbf42b7404633a5bfe7d455be125.jpg20220215_134118.thumb.jpg.985a77302da40970939370b63e04820f.jpg20220210_141316.thumb.jpg.4dda67dc79954cf7ea51e306705e1f71.jpg20220210_141307.thumb.jpg.ce61bcdb5758f3fafd40079a74ca078e.jpg

 

 

 

 

 

 

Edited by Gusar
Posted

Today is Columbus day, so ironically, it's a great time to work on your Santa Maria model. I assume you are using the Mataro Nave as a reference? It looks like you took a significant amount of features and replicated them on your model, which is probably a good decision. 

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted (edited)

Gusar

Just tuned in and I admire your model a lot.   Did the Spanish use belaying pins in the 15th century?  They are shown in your fifth row of photos in post #20.  The British did not use them until well into the 18th century so I am curious about this  as I am studying a 17th century Spanish vessel at this time and cannot find information based on contemporary sources that indicate they were used,   

Thanks

Allan

Edited by allanyed

PLEASE take 30 SECONDS and sign up for the epic Nelson/Trafalgar project if you would like to see it made into a TV series.   Click on http://trafalgar.tv   There is no cost other than the 30 seconds of your time.  THANK YOU

 

  • 3 weeks later...
Posted
On 11/2/2023 at 1:12 AM, allanyed said:

Gusar

Just tuned in and I admire your model a lot.   Did the Spanish use belaying pins in the 15th century?  They are shown in your fifth row of photos in post #20.  The British did not use them until well into the 18th century so I am curious about this  as I am studying a 17th century Spanish vessel at this time and cannot find information based on contemporary sources that indicate they were used,   

Thanks

Allan

Hi Allan,

 

I am not sure if Spanish used belaying pins in the 15.ct. In the book there are no pins drawn in Santa Maria plans only in Pinta plans. Also I saw on the SM replica in Palos de frontera there are belaying pins so I put them. I also tried to find out about this question long while ago, I think I found somewhere that the use of pins started in Mediterranean first. Need to check again.  Screenshot2023-11-18215338.png.9b067cae3e1fd5f268848f1138865dc9.pngScreenshot2023-11-18215923.png.ae03a20edac756e41da70c2f843a65ec.png

I have books about Spanish galleons in the 17.century if you need some help with your study I can check them. 

1-61d71054ab.thumb.webp.4a8dcd876e2727eb29406c6b273eefb8.webp

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...