Building Small-Scale Clinker Boats

[wefalck]

This has been buried deeply in my building-log for S.M.S. WESPE and not everyone is interested in 1870s warships. Thus, potentially interested people may have missed this description of building small-scale clinkered open boats. So, I decided to pull this part out, edit it for the purpose, and post it separately.

 

Clinkered open boats in small scale (the examples below are in 1/160 or N-railway scale) can be a challenge. The processes described below are based on paper parts cut with a small and cheap 3W laser-cutter. If one has a stronger laser-cutter, the same method can be used with thicker cardboard or even styrene and may give even crisper results. There are even various laser-cut kits for such small boats in 1/72 on the market.

 

Actually, the construction methods described below are adaptations of the well-known plank-on-bulkhead (POB) and plank-on-frame (POF) methods.

 

Starting point, of course, are a set of suitable plans, line- and body-plan, plus ideally information on the actual construction, dimension of scantlings etc.

 Example of a drawing for a gig from the early 1880s.

 

Two construction strategies are described one for boats covered with canvass, so that the interior structure is not visible and does not need to be modelled. The other example is for a plank-on-frame open boat model that shows all interior and construction details that one can possibly show at the chosen scale.

 

 

Plank-on-Bulkhead (POB) construction of open boats closed with a cover

 

Traditionally, one would carve a ‘plug’ for the boat from a piece of wood, that is based on the dimensions inside the planking(!). Such a plug can be re-used in case another copy of the boat would be needed. Otherwise, one can plank directly on the plug.

For the method proposed here, each individual framing stations from the body plan was redrawn as a bulkhead to be cut out with the laser-cutter. Additional material is left on the top, so that all bulkhead scan be glued to a building board arriving at the right height. As backbone, a longitudinal profile of the boat, inside the planking, is drawn. All pieces were slotted as it is common practice in POB construction. The slots were twice as wide as the paper, as all pieces were cut in double to be soaked and varnished together back-to-back with a view to increase their stiffness. In addition, two pieces that represent the outboard profile of the stem-post, keel, and stern-post were cut, plus two copies of the transom.

The bulkheads etc. were arranged on a drawing that controlled the laser-cutter. 

 

 Template for laser-cutting the keel-pieces and the stem-keel-combinations for a cutter

 

The material used is so-called Canson-paper, which is around 0.12 mm thick and an unglued, but heavily rolled paper. Its surface thus is quite smooth. This kind of paper turned out to be the most suitable for cutting with the low-powered (3W) laser-cutter.

 Laser-cut bulkheads and keel-pieces

 

The pieces then are assembled as is tradition for POB-construction and mounted onto a piece of Canson-paper for extra stiffness. The whole assembly is then mounted on a small piece of wood to ease handling.

The assembled parts for the POB-construction

 

To increase the stiffness of the assembly (which in fact is already surprisingly robust), the spaces between the bulkheads are filled with a hard foam. I am using an acrylic resin foam, that is being produced by the manufacturers of Plexiglas, but any hard foam will do. The foam is sanded back to the profile of the bulkheads and then soaked in varnish. Imperfection can be corrected with automotive putty. This will give ample surface for the planking to attach to. Note that due to their thinness, the bulkheads do not need to be bevelled.

 Foam-filled framework with three strakes on

 

The planks are laser-cut from the same paper. Tapering such planks by hand would be too much of a challenge and not quite feasible in paper, I think. However, my 2D-CAD program gives the length of the Bezier-curves used to draw the outline of the frames. So, one can simply take this length, divide it by the number of planks and add 50% for the clinker overlap in order to arrive at the plank width at each station. In reality that planks would overlap above and below only for about 25% of their width, but the extra width will not be seen on the completed model and gives extra leeway to accommodate small inaccuracies during construction. With this information somewhat too long planks were drawn with a few extras, as not all turn out well. A wider plank is provided for the garboard.

In theory, the planks should not only be tapered, but also curved in the plane, but I do not have a software to develop a full planking diagram. However, when wetted with varnish, the paper, unlike wood, can be relatively easily bent and shaped across the wide side of the plank.

Materials and tools for planking

 

When laser-cutting the tapered planks, the curves are so shallow, that the ‘stepping’ due to the 0.1 mm resolution of the cutter becomes quite pronounced. For this reason, the planks were drawn with a straight line on one side and the tapering curve only on the other. The straight edge will become the visible lower edge of the plank, while the stepped, curved side will disappear under the plank above.

When fitting the planks, the best way is to fix them in the middle first and then work towards the ends. As can be seen on some of the pictures, originally, I put the doubling of the stempost-keel piece in place before the planking in order form a rabbet against which the planks run. This turned out to be not very practical, as precise fitting is quite difficult with this material. Now I am drawing the backbone to the inside of the planking and add a false stempost-keel piece afterwards. This greatly facilitates the planking at the bow.

Planking progresses from the middle to the ends

 

All planks are cut flush to the interior backbone using a micro-scissors or cuticle scissors. When heavily soaked in varnish, the paper can be cautiously sanded. The soaking in fast-drying varnish has to be repeated after a few strokes with a diamond nail-file to prevent the paper from fraying.

In clinker construction, at the bow, where it meets the stem-rabbet, the lower planks are thinned out by the width of the overlap and over a length of 1.5 to 2 plank widths or so. In this way the planks are flush at the rabbet. This is a feature, that at this scale is neigh impossible to reproduce, so one needs to cheat a bit again. Luckily, as long as the varnish is still wet, the paper can be squeezed and moulded. The thinning can also be simulated by squeezing the edge with flat pliers or splinter tweezers that have been ground flat at the end. While the varnish sets, the edges are squeezed tight using locking tweezers. The same thinning procedures is applied to where the planks touch the stern-post or the transom.

Clamping the planks tight at the bows

 

The planking is done mostly by eye, as it is difficult to mark out the planking run with sufficient precision on such a small workpiece. It is advisable to use an organic solvent-based varnish for the purpose. A drop of acetone softens the varnish and allows to make small corrections in the run of the planking.

 

To be continued …

 

Edited October 17 by wefalck
Missing pictures

[tkay11]

Looking forward to the illustrations and the rest of the guide. Great idea.

 

Thanks

 

Tony

[shipman]

It would be convenient to me if the illustrations were jpeg files not png's.

[wefalck]

@tkay11 Sorry for the missing pictures initially. Don't know what happened to them, as they appeared while I was composing the post. Now corrected!

 

@shipman My original pictures are JPGs and uploaded as such. However, it seems that the MSW forum software converts these into PNGs so that their size can be automatically adjusted to the width of the screen. I have no control over that.

Edited October 17 by wefalck

[wefalck]

Continuation ...

 

Planking of a gig completed

Once the planking is completed, the excess material at the stem and stern/transom can be trimmed off flush. For this so-called cutting-tweezers as used by watchmakers to shorten watch springs are a very handy tool. The planked hull can now be given a coat of varnish to consolidate and further stabilise it. It then is rubbed down cautiously with fine (0000) steel-wool to smooth it. If needed, imperfections can be touched up with putty and sanded.

The next step is to glue the combination of keel and stem-post into place using the same varnish. This was laminated from several copies of the same laser-cut shape to achieve the necessary thickness. Any gaps can be filled with putty.

Many boats are fitted with rubbing strakes. Depending on how they look, they can be made from either very narrow laser-cut strips of paper or from thin wire that glued down with varnish.

 

Rubbing strake from 0.2 mm copper-wire installed on a gig

 

This basically completes the boat construction and it is ready to be cut from the building base. The next steps depend on how the prototype is arranged, i.e. whether it is suspended from davits, stands in chocks, or may be is placed upside down on a boat-skid. The bulkheads have to be cut down and the backbone be trimmed to a line that e,g, would be followed by the tarpaulin cover or that of the gunwale.

 

The completed planking on a cutter

 

If there are hoisting chains fore and aft to which the falls of the boat-davits will be hooked, only the top ring would be protruding from the boat-cover. This chain can simulated using a twisted-together piece of coper-wire of suitable thickness. The wire will be hooked into a bulkhead and glued down with varnish.  

Gig cut free from the building base (note: here the hull was not filled with foam)

 

Completed cutter cut free from the building board

 

Boats slung from davits or sitting upright in chocks are exposed to the elements and, therefore, often covered with a tarpaulin. The designs for such covers vary, but typically triangular pieces of canvass are sewn to the edges to which lanyards are spliced to tie the cover down. Other designs may use a draw-string in a hollow seam that goes all around the boat below the rubbing strake – much like purse-strings.

 

Very light-weight Japanese silk-paper for tarpaulins, sails etc.

Gig with simulated cover

 

The boat-cover is cut to the rough shape from a piece of thin silk-paper, draped over the boat and soaked in sanding filler. It is then smoothed down over the edges and down to the rubbing strake. Once dry the paper is cautiously cut back to the rubbing-strake with a new scalpel-blade. Now, if necessary, the canvass triangles can be added. The draw strings are only added after painting.

 

Rudder-pintles are made from short pieces of copper-wire or appropriate diameter and the respective bands are simulated by flattened copper-wire. All parts are cemented in place with varnish.

 

The boat is now ready for painting. The procedure depends on the colour scheme, of course. As the boat-covers are typically off-white (i.e. oiled canvas), it may make sense to give the whole boat a coat of white paint with the airbrush. This kind of basecoat (though technically not needed) allows to better see imperfections, that may need to be fixed before final painting. To be honest the results can be quite sobering: all the imperfections that were not visible in the ‘raw’ state now begin to stick out. Any jagged edges from the laser cutting that seem to disappear under the varnish become now rather visible. So some more filing and putty-work may be required. It is important to remember that we are talking about small boats, perhaps two to four centimetres long with a beam of barely one centimetre  …

 

Painted cutter in 1/160 scale

 

One should add, that laser-cut parts can also be used as templates (when drawn to the outside of the planking) for the frame-stations when carving solid hulls from wood to make carvel-built boats. They could be completed then with the same kind of laser-cut stem-keel-piece. Trying to build carvel-hulls with laser-cut paper planking may not be so successful, as paper does not sand very well. However, a good amount of putty could help here and at the bottom line may be quicker than carving with frequent checking of the shape against templates.

 

To be continued …

[BANYAN]

Thanks for this wonderful mini-tute Eberhard.  It is a great reminder of what can be done at such scales. The strakes turned out very symmetrical and look the real deal.  Those boats were very low in the water with a low freeboard by the looks of it.  When fully loaded the troops must have gotten a tad wet I think.

 

cheers

 

Pat

 

[wefalck]

Building fully framed open boats

 

The procedure is in principle similar to that of a boat that is covered. However, the bulkheads have to be drawn to the inside of the (bent) frames. The plug is built up in the same way as above. The plug built up from hard foam is then covered in a thin layer of automotive putty, which is carefully sanded down to the laser-cut templates. In order to prevent the structural parts of the boat from sticking to the plug, it is covered in cling-film that is drawn tightly over it, avoiding folds and creases.

This plug is mounted to a baseboard of two layers of paper laminated together with varnish. This baseboard has rectangular holes for holding the bent frames in place, which are cut with the aid of the laser-cutter. The baseboard is glued to a piece of wood that is a bit smaller than the inboard profile of the boat, which allows it to be held in a vice etc. to ease further manipulation. 

 

It is important to remember, that this method of construction only works, if the boat has no tumble-home. Otherwise, it will not be possible to remove the hull from the plug. For boats with tumble-home, one would have to carve a solid former from interlocking pieces that can be released successively and lifted out of the hull.

Laser-cutting templates for the formers and main structural components of a jolly-boat.

Plug for the POF construction

 

The bent frames are laser-cut strips of paper of the appropriate width. To achieve scale thickness, doubling may be required. The strips are bent around the plug, inserted into the rectangular holes, aligned carefully, and then cemented to the baseboard with varnish. If neede, they can be tied down in addition onto the plug with a length of wire that is tightened by twisting.

The backbone of the jolly-boat

 

The design of the stempost-keel-sternpost part is somewhat different from the previous construction. It is basically in two parts. One part is the part inside the boat and the other part is the one that is visible outside. The separation-line is basically the rabbet-line. The photographs give an idea of this. The actual outboard stempost-keel piece will be added later, after the planking. The interior part will be glued onto the frames now and the transom added.

 

It should be noted that there will be likely a couple of cant-frames that but against the keel/stem, rather than running under it. In consequence, these can only be installed after the planking of the hull is completed.

The framed structure

 

One may have noticed that this is the reverse construction order compared to the full-scale practice. A traditional clinker-built boat would be built over a couple of templates, with the planks going in first and the frames bent in afterwards – the ‘shell-first’ principle. I prefer the described method, because having the frames in place provides more glue surfaces than just the plank edges and thus makes for a stronger shell, when removing it from the plug.

The garboard-plank installed

 

I don’t want to hide the fact, the gluing and coercing down the planks here is a bit more difficult than when gluing them to the solid plug. As on any clinker-built boat, the garboard-plank is the most difficult to install due to its torsion and being curved in all planes. Here it is no exception. It needs a fair amount of coercion. Planking, of course, proceeds in parallel on both side of the hull in order to ensure symmetry.

Planked-up starboard side of a jolly-boat with the stempost-keel-combination also in place

 

After the planks are on, the outside part of the stempost-keel-combination is installed. With this one cannot really see that is was no real rabbet into which the planks run.

Looking down onto the planking; the overall length of the boat is 36 mm (just under 1.5")

 

The next step is to cut the excess length of the bent frames and to cautiously rock the hull in order to release it from the plug. The frames are then trimmed back to the sheer line. If part of the design, the additional (cant)frames will have to go in now, before the further fitting out can begin. The result is a quite strong hull with the typical exterior and interior look of a clinker-built boat. 

Cutting the extended frames with micro-scissors

Hull begins to detach from the plug

Hull successfully taken off the plug

 

Next go in the gunwales and the inwales on which the seats rest, all laser-cut strips of paper, doubled where needed and lacquered into place. Now the hull is given a coat of varnish and cautiously rubbed down with steel wool. Any imperfection visible can be touched up with putty, although it is likely, that more become visible once the first coat of paint has been applied to the hull.

Shell with gunwales and inwales

 

Most open boats have floorboards. These may be arranged in many different ways, but often are panels of several boards, which can be lifted out to give access to the bilge. Aligning these properly can be tricky and it may be a good idea to design them as a single unit, when the joining parts can be hidden under the seats etc.

 

Floorboards installed in the hull

 

At this small scale it is difficult to build precisely to the drawings, so that stern-sheets, seats, and other pieces may not fit exactly as drawn. This requires a bit of trial and error, and perhaps re-drawing for laser-cutting. Still a bit of sanding may be required for a perfect fit.

 

Sanding paper is not that much fun, but re-soaking it in lacquer after a few strokes with a diamond-file keeps fraying under control.

Stern-sheets, rowing seats and bow-platform installed

 

The remaining fitting out depends on the features of the prototype. There may be foot-rests for the rowers, pillars under seats, covering boards over the sheer-strake, strengthening pieces where the thole pins are inserted, reinforcements of the washing-strake around row-locks, mast-steps, etc. All these can be laser-cut pieces. There exact size and shape is best taken off the hull and drawings produced accordingly to control the laser-cutter. They are lacquered into place.

 

Depending on whether the iron hardware in the boats is going to be painted it can be installed now or left after the main part of painting has been done. The sequence of painting really depends on the kind of prototype.

Painted model of a jolly-boat on an ordinary port-wine cork

 

There will be various items of loose equipment such as the oars, rudders, fenders, a water-cask etc. that also can be produced with the aid of the laser-cutter.

 Painted model of a jolly-boat on an ordinary port-wine cork

The oars can also be built up from laser-cut parts. It may need a bit of trial and error to get the right shape and dimensions, as the laser-cutter can be somewhat unpredictable with such small parts. Each oar is lacquered together from three layers to build up their shape. The round of the shaft was built up with more varnish and sanded to shape using a diamond file. More varnish was applied before the paper showed signs of fraying.

 

Template for laser-cutting three-part Oars

Fully kitted-out jolly-boat in 1/160 scale.

 

The above lines are only intended to outline the principle of construction. Each boat-type is different and has different elements of construction.

 

While the description concerned boats with bent frames, the same principle could be used for boats with sawn frames. Again, the plug (if such was used) would need to be moulded to the inside of the now wider frames. Each frame needs to be cut out in multiple copies to build up the necessary thickness. Of course, if one has a stronger laser-cutter, one can use thicker paper/cardboard. The construction then is essentially that of POF and several commercial kits for such boats (albeit at a somewhat larger scale) are already on the market.

Comparison of a fully open and a covered boat in 1/160 scale

 

THE END

 

Edited October 18 by wefalck

[shipman]

That was a wonderful tutorial, Eberhard. Thank you.

 

Reffering to your response in your post #4.....

 

''My original pictures are JPGs and uploaded as such. However, it seems that the MSW forum software converts these into PNGs so that their size can be automatically adjusted to the width of the screen. I have no control over that''.

 

Your entire, marvelous 'WESPE' build images are ALL JPEG files.

Were these not also uploaded to the MSW as JPEG's, yet escaped the mysterious conversion to PNG?

[wefalck]

To be honest, I have no clue, why the pictures where converted to PNG. They were re-uploaded to these posts in the same way as the other pictures.

 

Also, there appear magically to images of the plug at the end of the post, that didn't put there and I don't manage to delete them ...

[shipman]

On 10/18/2024 at 11:45 PM, wefalck said:

To be honest, I have no clue, why the pictures where converted to PNG. They were re-uploaded to these posts in the same way as the other pictures.

 

Also, there appear magically to images of the plug at the end of the post, that didn't put there and I don't manage to delete them ...

Perhaps the moderators would care to comment, even re-convert the PNG images to JPEG?

[wefalck]

What operating system are you on and what kind of software do you have at your disposal? I am on MacOS and have Adobe Photoshop Elements. With the latter I can open PNG-files and then save them as JPEGs - quick and easy. It should also work with Apple's own 'Preview' software. I gather there are several other image processing software packages on MS Windows that do the same job.

[shipman]

My system is TOFFEE APPLE', held together with BUTTERSCOTCH.....can't be doing with all this virtual voodoo at my age.

Like if my dinner is on the plate, I'll eat it.

If not, then I'll starve.

Now if you don't mind, I have my IRONY BOARD to put away.

 

But I do appreciate your concerne and advice.

[shipman]

GADZOOKS!

 

What's happening?

 

I broached the subject of JPEG/PNG images on the 18th October, at which time I found your 'WESPE' build log images were JPEG files.

Today, 26th October, I decided to list the original page numbers where these small boats could be found for my and others convenience.

NOW the 'WESPE' build log HAS CHANGED TO PNG FILES!!!!!

 

I understand PNG files take less server space and it is becoming common practice to convert to this format.

This has nothing to do with Eberhard's intentions.....it's an administrators prerogative/choice.

 

I for one, don't like the change.

 

There are other sites of interest, where one finds all the images are only visibly clear subject to the viewer subscribing to an outside picture host.

Which means I have no interest in visiting those sites, no matter their content.

 

My point of view is why change something that has worked for years?

 

A logical progression could be access to the forum would require members to subscribe to an operating system which for many reasons I would not wish to do.

 

Sorry, Eberhard, for this issue to raise its ugly head within your post.

 

Perhaps the subject is worth opening it's own thread?

[mtaylor]

Hmm.... I'm not sure what's going on.  I spoke with the admins and there's been no changes to the site programs that could be causing this.