Jump to content

What wood is this? (Royal Louis 2nd planking)


Recommended Posts

I will really appreciate someone tell me what wood this is. 

 

It is used in my Mamoli Royal Louis to second plank the hull in the area below the main whales. Previous builders of this kit may have a clue???

Information in the kit is very confusing. In some places it says it is walnut and another some strange names. I'm sure walnut it is not!

 

If not certain, at least tell me please a close match. I am a bit worried that the material included in my kit will not be enough to finish the intended plank job, as some other people has said already. So I want to buy if not exactly, at least a batch of a close match. I'm sure a few planks scattered in a different shade will not look bad. It may be the opposite.

 

Thanks in advance for any input .

 

Ulises

 

 

post-975-0-43186200-1409778602_thumb.jpg

Edited by Ulises Victoria
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hello Ulises

 

I looked at my Royal Louis & I`m afraid I can`t tell for sure what it is. I don`t have my plans or instructions any more but I think it is what THEY call walnut.It looks very similar to the "walnut" that Mantua uses. I think I did have enough to do the planking below the whales - it was the lighter colored wood between the whales that I was short on.I think they called it boxwood.Sorry I can`t be of more help.It seems like in European kits the 'walnut" can range from a honey color to a very dark brown or almost gray - sometimes all on the same plank. :(

 

/Mark

Edited by marktiedens
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ulises,

 

Is the wood flexible in all directions?  It almost looks like beech.  I read somewhere that what certain manufacturers call their woods has nothing to do with what the wood actually is.  Can you post a bigger picture or a close up?

 

Hmm..  go here and click on wood samples:  http://www.dlumberyard.com/wood.html  Also here: http://www.wood-database.com/  Lastly, there is here... check the "domestic" and "exotic".   

 

Good luck.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mark, Beech is pink with brown speckles and very bendy. That material is walnut.

 

Hmm...  the beech I have is a brown not pink.  Different genus maybe?   I do have some walnut that looks his wood but there's something different about it...  I can't put my finger on it.  Again, it could be walnut specific to certain regions.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mark. Here are some closer photos.

Also, comparing the piece of wood with the sheet of paper included in the kit with different colors, the wood looks close to what they call "Beach wood" which I think they mean beech wood.

Unfortunately my photographic skills are not top notch and the color in the photos may not be very accurate.

I'm still confused.

 

Thanks all for your input.

post-975-0-28508600-1410135869_thumb.jpg

post-975-0-17609800-1410135886_thumb.jpg

post-975-0-19225000-1410136014_thumb.jpg

Edited by Ulises Victoria
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just a brief note on the variance of Walnut.

I have purchased both American Walnut and Peruvian Walnut (at least that's what they were called and both are much darker then your piece appears Ulises. The Peruvian is a lot darker then the American, that I have. I've seen others use (Ferit's Berlin comes to mind) what is called African Walnut, which looks this lighter color in pictures. I'd have some but haven't found a source so I can compare.

Not much help, I know, but I've seen huge variation in color of walnuts depending on their origins/variety/species, plus trees of the same species can vary from tree to tree depending on soil conditions and many other factors.

 

My guess is thats its a variation of Walnut, I'd guess African Walnut, but that's a guess.

It also reminds me of what I've seen other uses called tanganyika (I think that's the spelling) but I've never seen that wood so that's a guess.

 

Wood matching is a tough thing after the fact, even if you know what you have.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

The woodshown is what italians call walnut.

I have the same stuf in my prinswillem kit. The strange thing isthat in proper strips, the wood called walnut has amuch,much closer grain, and is qlso slightly differently colloured.

What the italian kitmakers call beach definitely has a punkish glos (especially the heat treted, flexible versionof it. )

Jan

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Many years ago one our my fellow club members went to Italy and visited the plant.  Mamoli and Mantua same parts.  He showed a video of his visit.  The use a sheer to cut their strips. The take several sheets of veneer into it and then cut the strips to width.  Many times the wood is still very green.  They do not have very good quality control.  A a result their wood will be different colors or not to good.

David B

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just to throw one more thought at this discussion, walnut varies more in color and grain than just about any other wood out there. Walnut has changed over the years because old growth naturally forested trees are hard to find in large numbers. Most walnut today is harvested from tree farming, smaller trees that have grown faster and thus have lower tannin levels which affects color and consistency.

The stain test was a great suggestion, especially against beech. I'm pretty comfortable calling the wood you have walnut. There are some African and South American species that look very similar to walnut but would be too expensive to put in a kit.

 

If you're not sure you have enough, buy more, group them into shades, when planking, pull from each group one at a time. this way you will not have patchy areas that stand out. I will be quite uniform and technically accurate to what would happen in the shipyard where thousands of square feet of lumber would all have to be used :)

 

Warm Regards,

 

Bill

Edited by Bill Hime
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ulises, your carving skills are superb and way above mine, which leads me to comment on this walnut selection.  Walnut has an open grain which detracts from the model appearance, especially in the smaller scales.  Even in the quarter inch scale, this open grain can still look poor.  Many modelers have used this walnut to good affect however, but if you want your carvings to have a home on a first class hull, I recommend you use a better species of wood, one that has a closed grain. 

 

If you are not adding your own carvings to this build, then Bill's advice above is sound.  You are the artist so you decide what looks best.

 

Duff

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...