Jump to content
NRG/MSW WEB STORE SALE - DON'T MISS OUT! - ONLY 4 DAYS REMAIN! ×

Bill Morrison

Members
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    682

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Everything posted by Bill Morrison

  1. Bill Morrison
    Great job so far! I have had my eyes on this model for a while. My wife tells me that I can sell off my stash and use the proceeds to purchase the kit. Yours is nicely done. Bill
  2. Bill Morrison
    I'm impressed! If you can, can we please have a detailed explanation about how you made them? They look great! Bill
  3. Bill Morrison
    I think that it looks great except that I am not looking at the difference in person. But, the photos look fine. Bill
  4. Bill Morrison
    I love the hull dimensions and appearance, but I appreciate the different calibers of the guns most. Few builders seem to appreciate this, but an excellent model can be spoilt by adhering to a single caliber on the gun decks and above. Impressive, Nek0! Bill
  5. Bill Morrison
    I fully agree. I have seen paper models that look great, but you are building an exceptionally outstanding model. Paper might not look right. Bill
  6. Bill Morrison
    First, I am most impressed with the advice presented here. It is so well articulated and justifies building all kits of the ship. To underscore the point, my first POB kit was an Aeropiccola 1/180 model given to me by my wife in 1979. The kit was basic in the extreme, with the instructions calling for simply drawing all gun ports and lids onto the model, with only the upper decks modeled with printed sheets in lieu of planks, and little detail. I learned the fun of greatly improving the model using my own skills, learning new skills, and researching better techniques to make a "real" model of the ship. Any model can be a fantastic experience. Second, HMS Victory is over 240 years old. Which era would you like to build? As built? Pre-Trafalgar? At Trafalgar? Post-Trafalgar? This question can have many possible answers. For example, while Caldercraft models the ship with raised forecastle bulwarks, no other model depicts her so. The Heller 1/100 scale plastic model shows her without the entry ports on either side. Mantua has three different models of her, each in a different scale. Some companies provide sheets with the gun ports pre-carved with exact measurements. In others, the builder must carve them out using templates. I can only describe the available kits as a smorgasbord of choices. All are good in their own way. All have weaknesses in their own way. Good luck with your choice! Bill
  7. Bill Morrison
    I have to second this comment. Your work is incredible! Bill
  8. Bill Morrison
    Marc, There are indeed quite a few exceptional models of SR that have been and are being built. One of my favorites was by a builder named David_K over on FSM from several years ago. I am waiting to see both yours and Nek0s models. By the way, I ordered that book about French Warships in the Age of Sail that you recommended. Bill
  9. Bill Morrison
    Marc, Yours is beyond doubt the most impressive model of this ship I have ever seen! I am a skilled modeler, but I tip my hat to you. Well done! Bill
  10. Bill Morrison
    I like using www.agesofsail.com as my "go to" for ship models of most manufacturers, tools, paints, references, a "how to" guide and fast service. I used to do business with Model Expo but they have gotten smaller over the years. Bill
  11. Bill Morrison
    Your HMS Mercury is STUNNING!!! I am inspired to try building this ship. Bill
  12. Bill Morrison
    My father got this kit for me back in the 1990s. It's a fun kit to build but there is one glaring error to me. It has no cannons. It is only an impression to me, but I believe that this type of ship did have some defensive armament. Bill
  13. Bill Morrison
    There is an interesting thread where the issue of belaying pins is discussed. I recommend it as an interesting read. introduction of belaying pins By hamilton, July 31, 2019 in Masting, rigging and sails
  14. Bill Morrison
    Credible representations are what the hobby is about. Marc is building a fantastic conversion of the Heller kit and painting it in an interesting and beautiful fashion! His model might or might not be a specific ship, but it certainly appears to be a French ship-of-the line, which he has based on credible plans. CRI-CRI is doing the same, as is the other Marc in France. Does this answer the question about belaying pins? We have conflicting information. Lees states explicitly that belaying pins first came into use around 1750. Was he talking specifically about English ships? Does he include French practice? Marc in NYC has provided some references about French warships of the period and paintings of Dutch ships. Looking at what appear to be belaying pins on the Dutch ships, I would not want to try to pick them up; their tops appear as large as my head (if not larger!). The Heller 1/100 scale plastic version has molded pins on the sheer rails. Unfortunately. these are sharply pointed, shaped badly, and fragile. Most wood plank on bulkhead kits don't seem to include them but I could be wrong. The Artesania Latina kit includes them on fife rails, which seems incorrect. I suppose the correct answer is to go with whichever the builder believes is authentic. Bill
  15. Bill Morrison
    Credible representations are what the hobby is about. Marc is building a fantastic conversion of the Heller kit and painting it in an interesting and beautiful fashion! His model might or might not be a specific ship, but it certainly appears to be a French ship-of-the line, which he has based on credible plans. CRI-CRI is doing the same, as is the other Marc in France. Does this answer the question about belaying pins? We have conflicting information. Lees states explicitly that belaying pins first came into use around 1750. Was he talking specifically about English ships? Does he include French practice? Marc in NYC has provided some references about French warships of the period and paintings of Dutch ships. Looking at what appear to be belaying pins on the Dutch ships, I would not want to try to pick them up; their tops appear as large as my head (if not larger!). The Heller 1/100 scale plastic version has molded pins on the sheer rails. Unfortunately. these are sharply pointed, shaped badly, and fragile. Most wood plank on bulkhead kits don't seem to include them but I could be wrong. The Artesania Latina kit includes them on fife rails, which seems incorrect. I suppose the correct answer is to go with whichever the builder believes is authentic. Bill
  16. Bill Morrison
    NekO, You gave an outstanding explanation of your point that the Tanneron model is "false". I appreciate your point of view. I suppose that we can look at all models of this period as being "false" if we cannot back up our models with documentation. At best we can use a medical description that the Tanneron model," . . . morphologically resembles . . ." French warships of the 17th-18th centuries. Indeed, the same description can apply to many ship models. Without specific evidence the Tanneron model is a facsimile. Concerning the belaying pin issue, we are all relying on secondary and tertiary sources. I am using Lees' book that was first published in 1979. Given that we are all using such sources we are all discussing based on very scanty evidence at best. Given this, I am open to everyone here offering an opinion. I would love to find primary sources to add to this discussion. Bill
  17. Bill Morrison
    Marc, Good morning. Okay, I see what you are pointing to. They certainly look like belaying pins at a glance, but they are far too large to be used as such. Even on the models, pins of that size couldn't be easily handled. They appear to be larger than a man. Maybe we have an answer to the mysterious "turnpins"! 😀 Bill
  18. Bill Morrison
    Marc, I will certainly look tomorrow. I discovered a similar discussion on MSW in August 2019 that sources Lees. The participants can point to a reference as early as 1750 in smaller ships but no reference before that date except for a reference to something called a "turnpin" that no one could define. They tried to pin i t down by using logic and reason, but no one was sure. Again, it does make an interesting discussion. Bill
  19. Bill Morrison
    Marc, Just as respectfully, I am inclined to believe just the opposite. Perhaps it's my age but I don't clearly see belaying pins in the paintings. The red arrow is pointing to what seems like carvings, but I could be wrong. But, I am enjoying this conversation. Thank you! Bill
  20. Bill Morrison
    According to my sources, the use of belaying pins did not occur until the 1790s. Granted, these sources might be talking about English ships, but they do not differentiate between navies. I have carved off all of the pins from the Heller kit and sanded the sheer rails smooth. But, again, there might be other opinions. Bill
  21. Bill Morrison
    Marc, Thanks. I appreciate it. Also, the Artesania Latina has quite a few problems. One issue is that they have used belaying pins in their advertisement, while the use of belaying pins came about almost 100 years later. Another is the lack of external decoration, her reputation being of a highly decorated ship. There are others commented about in the comments section for the model on You Tube. The kit has been around for about a month. Thanks for the reference. I will look it up and purchase of copy. Bill
  22. Bill Morrison
    Marc, Fair enough. May I have the specifics about the reference? Which book? Which author? Thanks! Bill
  23. Bill Morrison
    I'm confused. I thought that this is a model of the first SR but you say that she is pierced for 104 guns. The first SR carried 110 guns, the second carried 104. The gun displayed had to be of the first because of the sign claiming that it was off of SR in 1670, which is appropriate for the first. The second ship wasn't built until she was started in 1692. Could you please clarify?
  24. Bill Morrison
    Josh, I honestly don't know. It is probable that others have done so given that you found one. But, you really made out on that deal! Good job! It's also interesting to note that the Revell transom for the Constitution is also inaccurate for the 1812 period but not for the 1924 refit on which the kit is based. Bill
  25. Bill Morrison
    I'm extraordinarily impressed by CRI_CRI's effort with the Saint Phillipe, which also looks in many ways like SR. He would be an excellent person to talk with. Bill

About us

Modelshipworld - Advancing Ship Modeling through Research

SSL Secured

Your security is important for us so this Website is SSL-Secured

NRG Mailing Address

Nautical Research Guild
237 South Lincoln Street
Westmont IL, 60559-1917

Model Ship World ® and the MSW logo are Registered Trademarks, and belong to the Nautical Research Guild (United States Patent and Trademark Office: No. 6,929,264 & No. 6,929,274, registered Dec. 20, 2022)

Helpful Links

About the NRG

If you enjoy building ship models that are historically accurate as well as beautiful, then The Nautical Research Guild (NRG) is just right for you.

The Guild is a non-profit educational organization whose mission is to “Advance Ship Modeling Through Research”. We provide support to our members in their efforts to raise the quality of their model ships.

The Nautical Research Guild has published our world-renowned quarterly magazine, The Nautical Research Journal, since 1955. The pages of the Journal are full of articles by accomplished ship modelers who show you how they create those exquisite details on their models, and by maritime historians who show you the correct details to build. The Journal is available in both print and digital editions. Go to the NRG web site (www.thenrg.org) to download a complimentary digital copy of the Journal. The NRG also publishes plan sets, books and compilations of back issues of the Journal and the former Ships in Scale and Model Ship Builder magazines.

Our Emblem ®

Modelshipworld - Advancing Ship Modeling through Research

Nautical Research Guild ® and the NRG logo are Registered Trademarks, and belong to the Nautical Research Guild (United States Patent and Trademark Office: No. 6,999,236 & No. 6,999,237, registered March 14, 2023)

×
×
  • Create New...