Jump to content

tlevine

Moderators
  • Content Count

    1,348
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by tlevine


  1. Forget the gun ports on the plan.  I had originally planned on building them out but had to choose between spacing the frames equally apart from each other or incorporating gun ports.  Equal spacing won out because it made the butt shift easier to deal with.  Also, if you put in the ports it allows you to look into the hull as there would not have been any covers fitted to these ports.  There are a lot of things you can do with the hull once it has been planked including trunneling the hull, installing the ceiling, deck beams/planking, gun ports, hatch covers, etc.  I stopped where I did because I wanted to focus on hull planking for the beginner.


  2. At this point I am going to install the wale, or at least part of it.  For ease of bending this will be made up of two laminations of the same thickness as the planking.  This technique has the added advantage of using the second layer to disguise any slight gaps between the first layer of the wale and the upper row of hull planking.  The wale will be made up of two planks.  The first layer will have a butt joint located at the dead flat frame.   The location of the wale had already been drawn onto the frames and this was transferred to the tape.   I will be putting a scarf joint in the outer layer and its general location is also seen on the tape.  The scarf does not need to rest on a frame since it will have a solid piece of wood underneath it.

    194557228_Wale1a.thumb.jpg.30a826a48664b7e0ef6cd1ac582f4fc0.jpg

    Take a look at the end of the wale.  It does not rise above the counter.  There is a smooth line connecting the ends of the planks of the upper belt with the end of the wale.

    350921697_Wale2a.jpg.d8e7357e1b8121ae111f3b657c76a2d8.jpgCut out the two pieces of the wale.  Save the tape to reuse for the second layer.

    937192121_Wale3a.thumb.jpg.2b337647a36cd6d53cad251e43e8655e.jpg

    The wale will be a contrasting color.  I have chosen to "paint" the wale with archival marker.  The sides of the planks have been painted, even though they will not be seen.

    250187920_Wale4a.thumb.jpg.fcea0db27661d49ba91b19b7c42f1097.jpg

    1408615597_Wale5a.jpg.24265bf7ee9b391bb3cbff6497aa499b.jpg

     


  3. The lower two planking belts have been completed.  The next two rows of planking are no different than any of the other recent rows except that the aft ends terminate on the counter.  1261390920_Upperbeltrowone1a.thumb.jpg.5d66c3cbf36a88ba2d6d4440c05c1c8f.jpg

    Before going any further, I wanted to finalize the location and shape of the drop plank.  As I mentioned earlier, the kit goes through the technique of making a quarter-checked drop plank; this build log will utilize a half-checked.  These are always located just below the wale.  Using thin strips of tape I have marked out the forward rows of planking, with the drop plank terminating on Frame 5a.  After I was happy with the alignment, I drew the planking rows onto the frames.

    1142652347_Upperbeltrowone3a.thumb.jpg.89cc5b995f6957353676e60c561bb779.jpg

    1772629506_Upperbeltrowone4a.thumb.jpg.42d9fed7dae8bfb9947e577311d8f6b7.jpg

     

    Because of the multiple curves, I used small pieces of tape to determine the shape of the fore plank.  Transfer the plank width onto the tape from the marks on the frames.

    968321938_Upperbeltrowone2a.thumb.jpg.5e94ce5a91b6d435f32253485119eb65.jpg

    You can see that the width of this plank is wider than those in the middle planking belt.  I did not carry the middle belt high enough in front of Frame 2, causing this to occur.  If this was a "real" model I would have re-planked the middle belt.  But this hull will be joining its four siblings in a closet so I have chosen the lazy-person's way out and left it alone.  

    1272612615_Upperbeltrowone6a.jpg.f2aeb7fce5b374390f5c21a1ad8438ec.jpg

    1867873247_Upperbeltrowone8a.jpg.4f10d72ae5cf442a7e76b9c6188ae582.jpg

    619800380_Upperbeltrowone9a.jpg.75db86224c1703127bbf01d2b513ebf4.jpg

    The curve into the counter is actually very gentle and requires only a little encouragement to fit against the aft bulkheads.

    1264356719_Upperbeltrowone7a.jpg.a725dea85dc5c1e94f130cc72ad7c990.jpg

    2029721541_Upperbeltrowone5a.thumb.jpg.4f53c57da64d777cc31864534f3c6e2b.jpg


  4. The soft basswood dents very easily.  Consider putting a scrap piece of wood between the clamp and the plank to prevent damage.  There is only going to be one planking belt so instead of paper tic strips, take thin strips of masking tape and lay them on the frames from the broad strake to the top of the frame.  Decide how many rows of planking you are going to need.  I had ten rows but I did not use the kit-provided planks.  Measure the total length marked on the masking tape and divide by the number of planking rows.  Then, using a caliper, mark out the planking rows directly on the frames.  You will have no need for stealers or drop planks.

     

    Looking at the picture above, did you fair the frames enough fore and aft?  This is a picture from my build, showing the amount of sanding required to get a smooth planking run.

    Bulkheads installeda.jpg


  5. I cannot help you with the HTML stuff, sorry.  Your pictures are OK.  What do you use for photo software?  Securing the subdeck will help correct the warp but I would suggest adding some temporary battens along each side as well.  They can be removed as you start your first planking layer.  On a kit like this, the rabbet will be simply a bevel sanded onto the edges of the keel piece and the backbone.  It will help secure that first layer of planking but will have no impact on the veneer layer.  It should be easy to do.  The carbide drill bits you are using are extremely brittle, which is why they broke so easily.  Get some HSS bits instead.  Most of us only use the carbide bits in a drill press because they are so brittle.  The type of Dremel you are using complicates things because you are holding it with a pistol grip rather than just grabbing it in your hand.  This makes holding the Dremel perfectly still difficult.  I had one...emphasis on the word had.  Since you appear willing to spend a little money, I would suggest that you get a good quality pin vise for those tight spots and a straight moto-tool (either corded or not).


  6. Thank you to all the NRG members who attended the Conference in New Bedford.  It was great seeing both old friends and new faces.

     

    Work has resumed on the half hull project.  There are no complicated planks in the rest of the middle planking belt except for the aft plank in the top row.  The pictures show the general sweep of the planking followed by the appearance of the planks at the bow and stern.

     

    1509902112_Middlebeltrowthree1a.thumb.jpg.617a78a0012c91bc377fc93ce4dde904.jpg

    335588893_Middlebeltrowthree3a.jpg.df3b2fb820e8aa44db1b64d5662d5fd7.jpg

    1844464654_Middlebeltrowthree2a.thumb.jpg.e1e9bae993eca318fea15984b71960ae.jpg

    The aft plank of the fourth row lands on both the counter and the sternpost.  If you make a tape template it should not cause too much of a problem. 

    529415318_Middlebeltrowfour3a.thumb.jpg.468986c0fb40c2259811143d1d7825f9.jpg

    At the Conference several people asked my how I bend my planks.  The soft basswood only needs a little water to get it to bend.  I will typically clamp it in place, putting a scrap between the clamp and the plank to prevent dimpling.  After it has dried (no less than an hour) glue it to the hull.  With hardwoods this is more of a problem, sometimes requiring heat and moisture.  Never soak a plank in ammonia; it disrupts the wood fibers.  The photo shows the curve of the planking without any high or low spots.

    1339120766_Middlebeltrowfour1a.thumb.jpg.e26a913f738104d25334232999b103d8.jpg

    1624053632_Middlebeltrowfour2a.thumb.jpg.40ac61d5f74ae7f07ed5b538bd56f305.jpg

     


  7. Post a build log.  We are here to help, not criticize.  We are also good cheerleaders and teachers when the journey gets tough (and it will).  Your best tool will be patience.  Your second best tool will be solvent for your glue!  We all started at the beginning.  We all make mistakes, no matter how many years we have been building models.  On my current project (see below) I ripped out three rows of planking, costing me several days of work.  

    Just remember, this is a hobby...  Have fun with it; and if you learn something along the way even better.


  8. Ignore them.  They were designed to give the builder and idea where the planking belts run.  But each time I made the hull, the locations were just a little bit different.  The lower two marks are fore the garboard and broad strake.  The top two marks are the upper and lower borders of the wale.  The vertical line next to the "A" is the thickness of the backbone assembly.  


  9. This kit is designed as a teaching aid.  IMHO, the best teaching aid also teaches the teacher.  And this one reminded me that photographs will often find errors that the eye will not.  So even if you have no intention of posting your pictures, they can be very helpful modeling aids.

     

    Look at the above picture.  You can just barely see that there is a concavity in the planking at Frame 5.  This was a lot more obvious in the picture than in real life.  Looking more carefully, the problem is not that Frame 5 was sanded down too much.  Instead, I did not sand Frame 5a enough.

    453553443_Bowplankingerrora.jpg.ed2567a038f6df75a7e319836cb1f5eb.jpg

    My only option was to remove the involved planking and reshape Frame 5a.  The smudged ink is because I used a lot of isopropanol to dissolve the glue.  When you find it necessary to remove planks, do not even attempt to reuse them.  It will never look right.   

    1261619779_Bowplankingerror2a.thumb.jpg.f1761fb4870055af9995f7883da7befe.jpg

    1382130402_Bowplankingerror3a.thumb.jpg.663b9a651ea0971107196d88d716dcd1.jpg

    The result was worth it.

    600140732_Bowplankingerror5a.thumb.jpg.6f567201f7e2211ec6a2971b87b46ef7.jpg

    1002566935_Bowplankingerror4a.thumb.jpg.760514df3fd0b3cd1ecb5b6cf73395e1.jpg

    The build log is caught up to my construction progress.  The NRG conference is next weekend in New Bedford Mass.  I will be hosting (hostessing just sounds stupid) a round table on hull planking.  Hope to see some of you there.  Construction will continue upon my return home.


  10. The lower three rows of the middle planking belt are straight forward; there are no other stealers and the dropped plank is located in the upper belt.  The aft plank in the top row is complicated by the need to terminate on both the sternpost and the counter.  The photo below shows the plank above the stealer installed.

    866147481_Belt2Row1_2a.thumb.jpg.9be07f674a067f19592edd3746b6a922.jpg

    I used small pieces of tape to form the template for some of the planks with an extreme curve.  This will give a much more accurate template in these areas.

    1376941860_Belt2Row2_1a.jpg.0fc5d669ccad6346087f04a1044fa573.jpg

    1558754832_Belt2Row2_2a.jpg.1848b1ca2b95d1564badf646aab403c3.jpg

    996436578_Belt2Row2_3a.thumb.jpg.f81211df64f1c9987273b3146e99dca7.jpg

    1196540500_Piecesoftape1a.thumb.jpg.d67cdb3763e79284cadc4c875cbb4669.jpg

    1363129048_Piecesoftape2a.thumb.jpg.ee9955fbdbec75798e1c61e59130afe9.jpg

     

     


  11. This shows how the planks change shape.  The strips of tape are the templates for the middle and fore planks of row 3 of the lower planking belt.1694108122_Belt1Row3_3a.thumb.jpg.601cb2d4db46e1090f7727859d3ce898.jpgIn order to continue the appearance of the run of the planks paralleling the wale, the stealer will be placed between the lower and middle planking belts.  The forward location of the stealer will be, in part, determined by the location of the neighboring plank butts.  The photo below shows the area in question.  The previous row has a plank butt on Frame F and the planks two row either side have butts on Frame D.  You can still see the pencil lines for the quarter-checked (on the filler piece) and the half-checked stealers.

    120896846_Stealerredo4a.thumb.jpg.2832bdc6c9ddde1499e4752adfb09d68.jpg

    The first step is to make the aft plank which will be stolen from.  Don't waste too much time finalizing the width of the plank aft of Frame F because of the stealer.

    1204267690_Stealerredo5a.thumb.jpg.ba11f985391c4d05933505b63fe2a73d.jpg

    The yellow tape in the next two photos shows the shape and location of both a half-checked and quarter-checked stealer.  You can see that the width of the stealer at the sternpost is the same as the width of the other planks and how the upward sweep of the stealer more closely parallels the wale.

    838047914_Stealerredo6a.thumb.jpg.83a697a81eb614b6ab82fb6d95ee83ca.jpg

    2107475504_Stealerredo7a.thumb.jpg.57d11e1a95868e6fb7fd596d2d873146.jpg

    Make and install the aft plank.  I find it easier to cut the stealer into a plank that has already been glued to the hull.  I will be installing a half-checked stealer.  The kit takes one through installing a quarter-checked stealer.  In the picture below you can see that the location for a quarter-checked stealer is not correct.  Although the forward extent of the stealer is correct, I would have needed to steepen the angle of the stealer (compare with the photo above).

    294954256_Stealerredo9a.thumb.jpg.42620a0444c8372fc3c2f6b561d0c8ef.jpg

    Lay the template for the stealer over the plank, starting on Frame E and ending at the sternpost.  Draw the outline of the stealer onto the plank and cut the plank with a straight edge razor.  I do not like a #11 blade for this; a razor pressed into the plank will result in a straight line without the need to sand.

    2076379282_Stealerredo8a.thumb.jpg.32fcfd04068aa13c71c26547cfadc4e7.jpg
     

     

    1667755463_Stealerredo10a.thumb.jpg.a0c4c97c4dec6f313c38dfbe94e9558f.jpg

    And here is the final result.  Note the smooth transition between the stealer and the plank at Frame E.

    849326395_Stealerredo11a.jpg.2bdfe4d421b5520a4a775f9b111c6391.jpg

    Here is the lower belt completed with the stealer.

    1561250689_Belt2Row1_1a.thumb.jpg.f8e25d7c88f34df73c914bed5fc0ce9f.jpg

     


  12. It is time to start planking the belts.  There is more than one way to determine the shape of the bottom of the next plank.  An alternate approach would be to put a length of tape (or a strip of paper secured with tape) above the broad strake and take a compass to draw the shape onto the tape or paper.  Do not forget to locate the frame positions on the tape.

    1065250082_DrawingBottomofPlank1a.jpg.c1f97b65f3f8799bd5b00e54a4c1422a.jpg

    412522788_Belt1Row1_2a.jpg.18bc09ac21c82726eff2d644186afb2b.jpg

    Cut off the excess tape and finesse the shape against the broad strake.  For my convenience, I have drawn a wide line on the dead flat strake.

    1798820530_DrawingBottomofPlank3a.jpg.b5277fd2eae83870d661ddcdc0bb718f.jpg

    Using the tic strips mark the upper edge of the plank onto the tape and connect the marks with a ship's curve.  Leave the tape wide to prevent distortion and then put it on the planking sheet.

    1656309643_Belt1Row1_1a.thumb.jpg.84e3e9af1b53c73fe66012a68eb05f31.jpg

    Cut out the plank, leaving a little excess on both the top and bottom.  Trial fit the plank to the hull.  When happy, add the caulking lines and glue in place.

    259346167_Belt1Row1_3a.jpg.a404b81e2a4089fe31e6a2cf26d72594.jpg

    1802315986_Belt1Row1_4a.jpg.b3ba3d16d28df46db421c3fa7f5587ef.jpg

    Caulkinga.thumb.jpg.9b65454bc493a062e11a5743a5d47301.jpg

    Do this for all three of the planks in this row.  The result is a smooth curve when seen from both the side and below.  Take note of the height of the strake as it enters the bow rabbet: no smiley-face.

    310278137_Belt1Row1_5a.thumb.jpg.239840c2d818ff51b136ecae670e0b6b.jpg1529789472_Belt1Row1_6a.thumb.jpg.1c40511a530bfcb99f1383a96fef2f91.jpg


  13. Paul, welcome to MSW.  This project is designed in such a way that a true novice should not have much problem.  The only power tool I used was a Dremel, and even that is not necessary.  The following was stolen from Kurt's announcement in the Nautical Research Guild announcement section.

     

    We can now take orders for the Half Hull Planking Kit

    The kit is not yet listed at the NRG Store, and when it is, we will update this, but we can now take orders through the NRG Office.  Call the office directly or send an email.  See the NRG web site for the phone and email.  (Not listed here to thwart robots/spammers) 

     

    The price is $65.00 for non-NRG members.  NRG members get the member’s 20% discount price of $52.00.  Prices are plus shipping.

    US shipping is $15.00.  Canada shipping is $20.00.  Other non-US shipping is $26.00.

     

    Expected shipping is the week of 10-22-19. 

     

    And if you are lucky, Mary will convince you to join the Guild as well!

About us

Modelshipworld - Advancing Ship Modeling through Research

SSL Secured

Your security is important for us so this Website is SSL-Secured

NRG Mailing Address

Nautical Research Guild
237 South Lincoln Street
Westmont IL, 60559-1917

About the NRG

If you enjoy building ship models that are historically accurate as well as beautiful, then The Nautical Research Guild (NRG) is just right for you.

The Guild is a non-profit educational organization whose mission is to “Advance Ship Modeling Through Research”. We provide support to our members in their efforts to raise the quality of their model ships.

The Nautical Research Guild has published our world-renowned quarterly magazine, The Nautical Research Journal, since 1955. The pages of the Journal are full of articles by accomplished ship modelers who show you how they create those exquisite details on their models, and by maritime historians who show you the correct details to build. The Journal is available in both print and digital editions. Go to the NRG web site (www.thenrg.org) to download a complimentary digital copy of the Journal. The NRG also publishes plan sets, books and compilations of back issues of the Journal and the former Ships in Scale and Model Ship Builder magazines.

Our Emblem

Modelshipworld - Advancing Ship Modeling through Research
×
×
  • Create New...