Jump to content

schooner

Members
  • Content Count

    435
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by schooner

  1. Exterior hull planking done

     

    You can get away without planking this hull at all but I thought it would be good practice for me since I have the MS kit of the SYREN on the shelf and that kit calls for some good planking skills.

     

    While this kit is not a good choice for someone’s first build I do think it would be a good choice for a first planking job for the following reasons:

     

    • The hull will be completely painted so after priming and several coats of paint pretty much all of the plank seams and butts will be invisible - so will any learner’s mistakes - like mine
    • Planking a solid hull is easier than a POB hull since you have plenty of glueing surface, don’t have to worry about fairing the bulkheads and you can terminate a plank anywhere you want
    • The small size of the hull and the long lengths of supplied planking strips mean that you don’t have to cut most of the planks - they can run end to end
    • The supplied planking is 2mm wide and .02” thick so it is very pliable, which allows you to get away with easy edge bending, no soaking or heating to bend it and no spilling to avoid twisting. One drawback to it is that it allows you to get away with things that thicker planks would not so the planking “experience” you get from this kit is not all that it could be. That said I was able to add some drop planks, stealers and practice tapering. 

    IMG_20201019_110518.thumb.jpg.476caefdf7ac21d2718979f1882b29b6.jpg

    IMG_20201019_110531.thumb.jpg.f2eb4124440aae172623d954dcea095f.jpg

     

    Next on my to do list is to reopen the gun ports and then plank the interior of the bulwarks (ceiling)

  2. Nice looking boat! I thought it might be a Grand Banks.

    There is an interesting build log of Amati's Grand Banks kit, "Grand Banks by Mindi" https://modelshipworld.com/topic/24208-grand-banks-46-by-mindi-amati-models-120/

    I've been thinking of doing an RC build but I don't want to mess around laying fiberglass on a wood hull. This kit has a fiberglass hull but some very nice looking wood detailing inside and out. You could probably bash it into a good facsimile of your boat.

  3. I don't think you will have a problem with it sticking to the bondo but there is a real "gotcha" to watch out for - something I learned the hard way with scribed decking. Wood glue like Tite-bond or white glue like Elmers has a lot of water in it and it can cause thin decking material to swell, buckle or  warp. If you have enough decking material that you can spare some you might want to experiment a little - get a piece of wood (same type as the hull if possible), put some bondo on part of it (just to see if that will be a problem), sand it smooth and then pencil in an area on the top of it (not all the way out to the edges), cut a piece of decking the same size as the shape you drew , put on as much Tite-bond as you normally would (leaving a few spots bare to see if warping occurs, glue it on and see what you get when it is dry.

    You could go with slow (i.e thick) CA but that has it's own problems - you get very little time (if any) to move the decking around if you don't place it just right the first time.

    This may seem like overkill but on your Atlantic the deck will have a huge visual impact so you want to get it right.

  4. More Hull Planking

     

    Planking is coming along better than I thought it would since this is only my 2nd planking job and the last one was about 15 years ago.

     

    The instructions call for making the Garboard planks from a template but that implies having some thing to copy, which there is not. I found some mahogany strips in my stash that are wider than the kit planks and just a little thicker so they will be noticeable even though they will be painted. I read up on various build logs an shaped them as best as possible.

     

    IMG_20200926_093746.thumb.jpg.574428879ed2d7f9b2119b0c7b2e42c9.jpg

     

    I noticed on Chuck Passaro’s group build for the Winchelsea that ships of this period frequently had a drop plank at the head of both strakes below the wales so I made a couple out of the same strip material as the garboards, fitted them and then sanded them down so they are the same thickness as the rest of the planking.

     

    IMG_20200926_093822.thumb.jpg.5fc11f9cb1aa174afc39a7478f573f92.jpg

     

    I expected to have to taper the planks near the bow and add stealers near the stern but this hull shape is a little surprising. I’m going to have to taper both the bow and stern areas - I guess it is because being built as a merchant ship the ALFRED has a much deeper and broader “belly” since cargo capacity was more important than speed like it would be for a frigate.

     

    IMG_20201004_081342.thumb.jpg.232683d34ce3d8eb02a8ba28a5662af2.jpg

     

    IMG_20201004_081328.thumb.jpg.46bfe5da03903b8c81d4f5be0d7f6f02.jpg

  5. Bulwark planking

     

    The planking from the wales up to the top of the bulwarks is completed. This section was very easy to plank and without the need to figure out butt locations each strake went on as a single plank.

     

    Since I will be handling the hull a lot while planking the rest it I decided to hold off on reopening the gun ports - less chance of getting a plank end snagged on my clothes.

     

    IMG_20200924_150306.thumb.jpg.d3c68ea3c1ba8194beee3359d10f476d.jpg

     

    IMG_20200924_150327.thumb.jpg.bb253b4e65196472970a34625451024f.jpg

     

    Next up I’m going to try to make a template for the garboard strake and then put those in place.

  6. Hi Thunder,

     

    The box says she was built in 1777 but I think they got they wrong by a century. There was a frigate Alliance built in 1777 but she doesn't look anything like this. The second Alliance was built in 1877 as a gunboat and is a very close match for you kit, including the smokestack, and as the kit box says she spent quite a few years as a training ship You can Google USS Alliance and see photos or drawings of both ships.

    I have never heard of Pyro before but it looks like an interesting build.

    Good luck with her.

     

    By the way, the photos of your completed builds are very impressive - wish I could plank like that!

  7. Start of hull planking

     

    The first thing I put on were the wales. The instructions call for 2 strakes but per the plans the wales are 1/4 inch high and the material provided is 1/4 inch so at some point the wood strip provided must have changed from 1/8” to 1/4”. I checked my spare parts bin and found some 1/8” of the right thickness and I went with that since it is much easier to edge-bend 1/8 than 1/4. As it worked out, I did not need to heat or soak the wale strips to get them around the bow.

     

    IMG_20200918_131540.thumb.jpg.ea89c0fffcae8953c5bd47b6a6114284.jpg

     

    Next up I did the counter earlier than the instructions call for because I think it will  be easier to get a neat intersection between the hull and counter planking this way.

     

    IMG_20200918_131603.thumb.jpg.05303181803ea5c37b04d435304484de.jpg

     

    I’ve started to plank the outer bulwarks, following the instruction’s suggestion to just plank over the gun ports in order to keep the planking seams aligned. I’ll cut out the ports again when I’m done (and do it a 3rd time after planking the inside of the bulwarks.)

     

    IMG_20200918_131613.thumb.jpg.2b629fc447c0ae728836a58c6b6c19d7.jpg

  8. Planking preps

     

    There were a couple of things I needed to take care of before starting the planking.

    I deepened the rabbets on the stem and sternpost so they will hold the plank ends. Using the gun ports as references I marked the location for the top of the wales and the height of the bulwarks to match the plans. For the hull I received, the bow area was right on, the waist needed to come down a little, 1/4” or less, and the aft most 2” needed to come up just a little - something I had already added and then ended up removing most of it.

     

    The final item was something I have not done before. The instructions call for coating the hull with thin CA glue and then lightly sanding it to give a smooth surface for the planking that will also resist soaking up most of the planking glue. Since this is the first time I will try planking a solid hull it made sense to me so I did it.

     

     

    IMG_20200912_103503.thumb.jpg.b9191d57f826e50a09f5f7272ee34445.jpg

     

    IMG_20200912_103454.thumb.jpg.8e59271b09714f17634ed75810ba948d.jpg

     

    Next up will be attaching the wales and then planking the bulwarks.

  9. Finishing up the gun ports

     

    After filing 3 or 4 a day I finally finished all 20 gun ports.

     

    IMG_20200909_084758.thumb.jpg.9336dade016ce692d7c4604952d6b88d.jpg

     

     

    I used my test cannon to confirm that the gun barrels were centered in the ports, they were - almost. There was still a small “shelf” of wood right at the base of the ports that I could not see or even feel with my finger but when I pushed the cannon right up to the bulwark it would rise on almost all the ports so I had to speed a fair amount of time using what amounts to a milling cutter on the Dremel slowly going over that area until the guns are all centered.

     

    IMG_20200909_084807.thumb.jpg.b15532ac4f8e6c86e618b86b8a2cfa94.jpg

     

    IMG_20200909_084820.thumb.jpg.0dbbe6a454ded8d18931a458a3a82036.jpg

     

    The next steps will be getting the hull ready for planking.

  10. One trick for filling small cracks is to use white (or Elmer's) glue. It has the strange property that if you are filling in a small crack or gap, say between a deck and a vertical bulkhead, the glue not only fills the gap but it tricks the eye into not even seeing the filled crack even though the glue dries transparent. That has really saved me a couple of times where I had 2 surfaces painted different colors that would have been tough to tape off and paint - white glue made the problem invisible1

  11. Laying out the gun ports

     

    I’ve been spending a LOT of time measuring, marking, comparing, erasing, remeasuring, etc, etc, etc as I’ve tried to figure out where the gun ports are supposed to go. It’s no surprise to anyone on this site that one of the great things about working with wood is that there are few unrecoverable errors but getting the gun ports wrong on a model of this size might be one of them so that is why I have been doing all the ruminating.

     

    In the process of figuring out where the gun ports go I also dry-fitted the PE transom and figured out I would need to raise the after part of the bulwarks a little so I added a 1/8” strip and then sanded it down to match the sheer of the quarterdeck.  Later on I’ll probably have to take off most of what remains.

     

    IMG_20200826_104446.thumb.jpg.813ff6f2ed0f0e8f3a5b176906a5659a.jpg

     

    IMG_20200826_121822.thumb.jpg.e67937b1530170c988eea65a6c968b3c.jpg

    The instruction call for laying out the gun ports using the station lines and the waterline. I did a little of the former and ignored the latter. I finally figured out that the key reference for the gun ports is the height/location of the gun deck at each port location. If the port is too high or too low it would be a real mess trying to fix it so the cannons will protrude properly.

     

    Since all the station lines are probably a little off because of the difficulty bringing a line from the keel to the bulwarks I decided to just pick an amidship station line and then mark the fore and aft lines for each gun port from it, that way only the error of one station line is included rather than the compound errors of using all the lines. The only exception was for the forward most port on each side - the plan's side view can't account for the curve of the bow so I measured their location from the stem using the overhead plan.

     

    To lay out the upper and lower limits for each port I used a trick from the instructions;

    • I put together the carriage and barrel for one of the cannons, glued it to a small piece of the decking that will cover the gun deck and then pushed the barrel up against the inside of the bulwark at the port’s approximate location (note for anyone building this kit - the instruction book and parts list both refer to 1/16" scribed decking, my kit has 1/32", which is fine with me since it will be easier to work with.)
    • I made a pencil mark and then transferred that mark to the exterior of the bulwark and drilled a small hole.
    • If the hole matched the interior pencil mark I knew I had the line for the center of the port, if not a made a correction and drilled another hole until I got it right. Then all I had to do was measure from the port’s center mark up and down to get the port’s vertical dimensions marked.

    IMG_20200829_091826.thumb.jpg.43b167e0f50cb7e8bf0f6019ae74044e.jpg

     

     

     

    Once everything was marked and checked against the plans again I was ready to start cutting them out (or to put it more accurately drill and file them out). It is a little slow going, I can only do one port in a sitting or I’ll get careless. 3 down, 17 to go.

     

    IMG_20200830_082116.thumb.jpg.8a4deb2ec9d4baba57b9b0b4f8692393.jpg

     

     

  12. I'm working on a 1775 vessel that was built too early to be coppered. All the models I've seen of ship's of that period show a white coating below the waterline which I assume is some sort of white lead to combat worms and other destructive organisms.

     

    My question is: In order to accurately represent that underwater coating should I assume it was put on so thick that individual planks were not really visible and therefore I should use filler on my completed planking in that area so that I will have a smooth finish. Most builds I've seen seem to have smooth, off-white underwater hulls but usually the photos are not close-up enough to tell about the plank seams.

     

    Any feedback would be appreciated.

  13. Thinning the bulwarks

     

    This is the step that I have been dreading, I’ve never had to do it before on any of my builds and I’m not very good with chisels so the thought of having to reduce the bulwarks by about 80% to only 3/32” thickness almost kept me from buying this kit.

     

    The instructions go thru the same process for thinning that I have seen on build logs using a hobby knife, small saw, chisels, files and sanding blocks but it also mentions that a rotary tool can be used so that was they way I decided to go and it turned out to be much easier and less time consuming than I could have hoped for.

     

    The bulwarks start out at about 3/8” thick. They need to come down to 3/32”, at least at the top, and the bottoms can be 5/32 but 3/32 is more accurate. They also have to slope inboard as they go up (tumblehome) but since the ALFRED started out as a merchant ship the instructions said she would not have had as much tumblehome as a purpose built warship.

     

    I figured out that the best way to handle the tumblehome was to sand the curve shape into the outboard side of the bulwarks, then as long as I maintained the same thickness from top to bottom the inside of the bulwarks would have the same inward slant or curve.

     

    I marked the transition point where the bulwarks go from slanting to vertical where the curve of the bow begins - that would be the forward limit for shaping the outside of the bulwarks. I also marked the location the wales - that would be the lower limit. Using a hand held vibrating sander it was quick and easy to bring the thickness down to the outboard line on the top of the bulwarks (see the last photo of the previous post) then to impart a curve from the top to the lower limit line. By looking at the hull frequently I was able to remove any flat spots and keep everything fair. This is how things looked after the outside was done; (not sure why the sternpost looks crooked in the following photos - when I saw them I thought "Oh no, how could I have missed THAT!!!) but when I checked the model the sternpost is straight and plumb. Guess my photo skills are worse than I thought)

     

    IMG_20200821_085722.thumb.jpg.d2118f0cc301d38fec8a0a2e1e020169.jpg

     

    IMG_20200821_085726.thumb.jpg.037b0bafb2466689a5a96f1a5653d1d8.jpg

     

    This is what I used to handle the inside of the bulwarks:

     

    IMG_20200823_112642.thumb.jpg.2fcde59540bac82f80500b4681f6aa70.jpg

     

    The rotary sanding drum took care of most of the work. The calipers are essential for this job. I started out to bring the bulwarks down to 6/32 along their entire length, checking frequently with the calipers. After that is was just a matter of setting the calipers at 5/32, and repeating each 1/32 until everything was 3/32 thick. Its important go sloooow and use a light touch keeping an eye on the orientation of the sanding drum to the wood. Be ready to deal with a LOT of sawdust. When finished it's surprising how thin 3/32 is, so thin that they are translucent when held up to light!

     

    IMG_20200823_112717.thumb.jpg.acfb6e9d0cad889e7699804ed05c8854.jpg

     

    IMG_20200823_112708.thumb.jpg.2c9bb88dd9843653834cd6c38ff32275.jpg

     

    IMG_20200823_112604.thumb.jpg.ca8b2c7e8c42eb1b630b775dcfa4759b.jpg

     

    The only remaining job, and one that took about as long as everything else combined was the rotary drum left a “shelf” along the deck about 1-2mm high were the bulwark has been removed. The cutters shown above were used along with sanding sticks and a sanding block, and even a curved chisel to make the corner  between the bulwarks and deck sharper. I may have to do a little more in that area when it comes time to fit the scribed decking.

     

    I plan to plank the inside of the bulwarks (ceiling) and the outside wiich will bring their thickness up to 4/32, thin enough that the cannon barrels should extend far enough out of the gun ports to look realistic.

     

    Next step will be making the location of the gun ports and cutting them out.

×
×
  • Create New...