Jump to content

Welcome to Model Ship World
Register now to gain access to all of our features. Once registered and logged in, you will be able to create topics, post replies to existing threads, give reputation to your fellow members, get your own private messenger, post status updates, manage your profile and so much more. If you already have an account, login here - otherwise create an account for free today!
Photo

Copyright - beware


  • This topic is locked This topic is locked
27 replies to this topic

#1
dvm27

dvm27
  • Members
  • 1,092 posts
  • LocationBaltimore, MD

I know copyright has been discussed ad-infinitum here but this dovetails into the post by Chuck the other day on pulling photos from the interned and posting them here.

 

There are companies that troll the internet on behalf of photo distributors searching for copyright protected photographs. Once they locate one, they contact the owner and strong arm the offender with threats and a high fee to resolve the grievance.  One of my employees saw a cute photo of a dog with a bandaged leg and put it on our website a while ago. I received a strongly worded e-mail to take it down immediatly and pay them $800 or the fee would continue to rise. I did some research to discover the photo distributor and am in the process of negotiating a settlement, thereby bypassing the heavy-handed third party. 

 

Our web posting protocol has now been heavily modified and, if Chuck seems paranoid about random photos and material, it's because there are people out there looking for such offences and wanting to profit from them. An expensive lesson for me


  • Chuck, Ryland Craze, cog and 29 others like this

Greg

website
Admiralty Models

moderator Echo Cross-section build
Admiralty Models Cross-section Build

Finished build
Pegasus, 1776, cross-section

Current build
Speedwell, 1752


#2
dafi

dafi
  • Members
  • 1,850 posts
  • LocationLudwigsburg Germany

The same in Germany ...

 

For our german forum we had unfortunately to hide half the building reports and especially the research section for that reason and only can grant access after registration - no remedy but a tiny bit of privacy that makes us less vulnurable.

 

Also NMM requests to always to properly mention the source - as plenty of other sources do. But not just for them, it also makes our own work easier, if one knows where the stuff comes from for further research.

 

Also often pictures from build logs from other forums are used without the source being told. Always unfair to the original maker!

 

Cheers, Daniel

 

http://www.segelschiffsmodellbau.com


Edited by dafi, 22 January 2016 - 03:15 PM.

  • cog, riverboat, mtaylor and 8 others like this

To victory and beyond! http://modelshipworl...ory-and-beyond/

 

By the Deep 17 http://modelshipworl...-display/page-4

 

SMS Trinkstein http://modelshipworl...navy/#entry3314

 

See also our german forum for Sailing Ship Modeling and History: http://www.segelschiffsmodellbau.com/

 

 

Finest etch parts for HMS Victory 1:100 (Heller Kit) and other useful bits.

http://dafinismus.de/index_en.html

 

Honorary Member of the Tic-Tac-Man-Appreciation-Society


#3
Erik W

Erik W
  • Members
  • 368 posts
  • LocationLongmont, Colorado, USA

One good rule of thumb for members of MSW is, if it's not a photo you took yourself, post a link to the photo, rather than the photo itself.  While not as visually pleasing as clicking into a topic with the photos already there, as a viewer you're still only a click away from seeing the photo.  And it saves the hassle of potential copyright issues.  :)

 

Erik


  • riverboat, mtaylor, ccoyle and 20 others like this

#4
daddyrabbit1954

daddyrabbit1954
  • Members
  • 397 posts
  • LocationTampa, Florida

What a litigious world we live in today. Lots of land mines out there, for sure.

While I'm no lawyer, I wouldn't be surprised if some people/companies use strong-arm tactics to extort money from people whether the law would actually support their claims or not. Just the threat of having to defend yourself in a lawsuit is enough to cause many of us to pay off, just to mitigate the damage.

It is well known there are many such companies out there who will do exactly that.

All that being said, the most sage advice is likely what the previous poster just said...unless you took the picture yourself, don't post it. 

 

Craig


  • mtaylor, CaptainSteve, Martin W and 5 others like this

#5
Chuck

Chuck

    Administrator

  • Administrators
  • 7,316 posts
  • LocationRutherford Nj

Very true......I will of course copy and paste this original post by Greg into the topic of Amazing photographs.  We were contacted on two occasions by folks who owned the pictures copied and pasted in their by our members.  Luckily the owner only wanted recognition and we edited the posts to reflect that.

 

We basically have two or three members who just troll the web and facebook for photos and repost them here and it is very dangerous for us.  All attempts to get one of them to stop has been futile.

 

But please do keep this mind.

 

What is socially a fun thing for you to do turns out to be a nightmare for our staff and also frustrates other members who have to look between your posts like this for anything else worthwhile.

 

Chuck


  • mtaylor, davyboy, michael mott and 17 others like this

Chuck Passaro - MSW Admin 

 

Current build - HMS Winchelsea - POB scratch build

                            HM Cutter Cheerful - POB scratch build

       Royal Barge - POF scratch

 

www.syrenshipmodelcompany.com

 


#6
dafi

dafi
  • Members
  • 1,850 posts
  • LocationLudwigsburg Germany

One good hint is that the poster personally can be made reliable for putting up pictures that suddenly get expensive.

 

More easy to claim with a mostly german forum than an international one ...

 

... and it always will stay a hazard for the forumĀ“s crew in especially the owner.

 

Cheers, Daniel


Edited by dafi, 22 January 2016 - 05:56 PM.

  • mtaylor, Captain Slog, CaptainSteve and 2 others like this

To victory and beyond! http://modelshipworl...ory-and-beyond/

 

By the Deep 17 http://modelshipworl...-display/page-4

 

SMS Trinkstein http://modelshipworl...navy/#entry3314

 

See also our german forum for Sailing Ship Modeling and History: http://www.segelschiffsmodellbau.com/

 

 

Finest etch parts for HMS Victory 1:100 (Heller Kit) and other useful bits.

http://dafinismus.de/index_en.html

 

Honorary Member of the Tic-Tac-Man-Appreciation-Society


#7
Chuck

Chuck

    Administrator

  • Administrators
  • 7,316 posts
  • LocationRutherford Nj

To see how funny this isnt.....check out the Amazing Photographs forum......see how much trouble this creates with a recent development that could be costly........ :angry:

 

http://modelshipworl...289#entry382024


  • mtaylor, GLakie and Canute like this

Chuck Passaro - MSW Admin 

 

Current build - HMS Winchelsea - POB scratch build

                            HM Cutter Cheerful - POB scratch build

       Royal Barge - POF scratch

 

www.syrenshipmodelcompany.com

 


#8
overdale

overdale
  • Members
  • 424 posts
  • LocationCentral Virginia

Very true Chuck.

 

I have found photos of my work lifted from my website (mostly shipwreck models) on other websites. I have no problem with people using them as long as they say where they got them from.

 

I have had requests to use the photos and I always agree as long as there is attribution, but they are mostly from people publishing some sort of report or book where they are already aware of the problems of copyright.

 

Dan.


  • Chuck, mtaylor, CaptainSteve and 2 others like this

#9
Chuck

Chuck

    Administrator

  • Administrators
  • 7,316 posts
  • LocationRutherford Nj

Reminder....

 

If you don't own it, or you didn't take the photo yourself........seek permission to post it.  

 

Or don't post it....  

 

Please give the photo owner credit and post where you got the image from....  If it has a watermark....don't post it unless you include a few words on how you have received permission to post it.

 

If you spot a post that looks like a copyright was violated...please report the post so a moderator can take a look at it.  

 

Please dont copy and paste photos from other sites without doing your due diligence first.

 

Thank You very much in advance.......repeat offenders will be warned....or worse


  • mtaylor, Dubz, druxey and 6 others like this

Chuck Passaro - MSW Admin 

 

Current build - HMS Winchelsea - POB scratch build

                            HM Cutter Cheerful - POB scratch build

       Royal Barge - POF scratch

 

www.syrenshipmodelcompany.com

 


#10
mtdoramike

mtdoramike
  • Members
  • 1,193 posts
  • LocationCentral Florida

There should always be a banner posted on any open forum regarding copyrighted or protected material. People tend to think just because something is posted on the internet, it makes it open season, but it does not, especially when you start quoting people copying and pasting articles and so forth. We like it here and don't want any trouble so's you's guys need to knock it off and either create your own or don't bother.

 

 

mike 


  • Chuck, mtaylor, druxey and 3 others like this

#11
Chuck

Chuck

    Administrator

  • Administrators
  • 7,316 posts
  • LocationRutherford Nj

Thank You....

 

Also keep in mind that "borrowing" photos from Flickr or facebook is never a good idea.   See this link.  

 

Link removed because topic was deleted as planned...

 

Slowly scroll down the page.  You can see how many that are now broken and not doing anything positive for MSW.   You were a busy beaver Crackers.

 

Remember also that this is how photographers make their money.  Its no different than any other business.  Respect the copyrights of others!  Just ask for permission.  99% of the time they will be fine with it.  Just dont be afraid to spend the time to get permission.  

 

Thanks again  :)


  • Ryland Craze, mtaylor, dgbot and 8 others like this

Chuck Passaro - MSW Admin 

 

Current build - HMS Winchelsea - POB scratch build

                            HM Cutter Cheerful - POB scratch build

       Royal Barge - POF scratch

 

www.syrenshipmodelcompany.com

 


#12
Cathead

Cathead

    Eric

  • Members
  • 630 posts
  • LocationMissouri, USA

Here's another reason to be careful reposting pictures: those photos are still hosted on the original server. That means, whenever someone loads a MSW (or any internet) page with a linked photo, the computer goes and grabs it from the original server, creating traffic for that site. Sometimes, reposting a photo that a whole bunch of people see means really elevated traffic for the original site. Great, right? No. Because some sites, especially smaller or personal ones, have bandwidth restrictions based on what they pay for hosting. If a photo on that site suddenly starts getting a ton of traffic, it can bump that site out of its paid bandwidth, and either shut the site down for overuse, or cause the site's owner to get a bill from the hosting company for extra service provided. As someone who manages his own site for business purposes, and has a lot of photography there, this is a real potential problem.

 

The internet is often compared to a plumbing system. In this case reposting photos is a bit like tapping into someone's water line to taste their water. In small doses it often doesn't matter, but 1. it's still stealing, 2. if you add that straw and lots of other people start using it, you're really stealing and driving up their water bill, and 3. it doesn't benefit them because the other drinkers don't realize whose awesome water they're drinking.

 

We all do this from time to time, it's too easy not to. And sometimes it's from a site that really is public domain or otherwise not a problem. But thanks to Chuck for helping us all think about how and why we do it.


  • mtaylor, ccoyle, dgbot and 13 others like this

Current build: US Revenue Cutter "Ranger", Corel, 1:64

 

Previous builds:

Naval: 18th century longboat, Model Shipways, 1:48; Naval gun kits from Model Shipways; Bounty launch, Model Shipways, 1:16

Missouri River craft: Missouri River steamboat Bertrand, scratchbuilt in 1:87;  Lewis & Clark barge, scratchbuilt in 1:48;
Missouri River keelboat, scratchbuilt in 1:87; Missouri River steamboat Far West, scratchbuilt in 1:87


#13
mtdoramike

mtdoramike
  • Members
  • 1,193 posts
  • LocationCentral Florida

I love that analogy cathead.

 

mike


  • mtaylor, dgbot, Captain Slog and 5 others like this

#14
Jack12477

Jack12477

    Hard water sailor

  • Members
  • 1,346 posts
  • LocationSaugerties, Mid-Hudson Valley/Catskill Region, NY

Crackers, many years ago I had the opportunity to attend a employer sponsored week-long  R&R type seminar. One of the many speakers was the Chairman of the Copyright and Patent Law department at Columbia University Law College. His talk was on Copyright and Patent law.  He started his talk by giving us the legal definition of Copyright; then to help us understand it better he gave an example. The example was this:

 

"You're a teenager at summer camp,. You go to the camp store, buy a postcard and stamp; on one side you place the stamp and your parent's address, on the other side you write 'Hi Mom and Dad, having a great time at summer camp. Food is great. Love Joey" and you mail the card to your parents."

 

He then explained that what had been written on the postcard was Copyright because it met the definition.  To further illustrate he gave a second example

 

"You go on vacation with your family to one of the National Parks and while there take lots of photographs. When you come home, you take your film (this was pre-digital photography) to the drug store to be developed and printed"   Your printed photographs are now Copyright.

 

He further explained that the circle-C symbol or the word Copyright does not have to be emblazoned on the work - all tho it enhances the protection. The protection exists from the moment you place the work into a media and publish it. And the work does not have to be registered with the US Copyright office - altho that is the best protection - to be Copyright.

 

By his explanation, every photograph, every note to Mom & Dad, every finger painting your kids ever did - all are immediately protected by Copyright.

 

Now I've given a very simplistic example of Copyright but be wary - someone somewhere owns the Copyright - even our own build logs and photos of our models are protected by Copyright - ever notice that Dirk (Dubz) explicitly stamps his photographs with "Copyright Dubz 201x"

 

Now there is the Fair Use Act under Copyright law but that I will leave that to the members to research for themselves.


  • Ryland Craze, mtaylor, ccoyle and 9 others like this

Jack
 
"No one is as smart as all of us"
---------------------------------------------

Current build: MS Willie L Bennett
Completed build log(s): MS 18th Century Longboat , AL Marie Jeanne
Gallery: AL Swift , AL Armed Virginia Sloop, AL Santisima Trinidad Captain's Launch , 18th Century Longboat , AL Marie Jeanne
In dry-dock: AL 1798 US Constellation,  MS Picket Boat,  Dumas Donzi Z65 Tournament Fisherman (R/C)

Other: 1912 Hudson River Ice Yacht Manhasset - RESTORATION - Scale = Full Size, Relief Carving for Model Ships


#15
flyer

flyer
  • Members
  • 609 posts
  • LocationLenzburg, Switzerland

How about using scanned cut-outs from books?

 

Occasionally I used in a discussion here such parts of books illustrations to  emphasize one point or another. Although I always wrote what book the illustration came from I never had explicit permission from the author. I always thought that I was doing free promotion for those books but I believe now, that I may also have violated copyrights.

 

How do you see that?  

 

peter        


  • mtaylor and Canute like this

current build:

Yacht America by flyer - Mamoli - scale 1:66 - with some alterations

completed builds:

Dolphyn Corel 1/50

Wasa Corel 1/75

La Gloire C.Mamoli 1/90

HM Bomb Vessel Granado JoTiKa   HM Bomb Vessel Granado 1756 CC kit 1:64

Victory Models 1/64 HMS Pegasus by Flyer

HMS Pickle, my interpretation


#16
Jack12477

Jack12477

    Hard water sailor

  • Members
  • 1,346 posts
  • LocationSaugerties, Mid-Hudson Valley/Catskill Region, NY

Peter, simple answer is it falls under Fair Use Act - Do a Google search on Fair Use Act Copyright Law - it's complicated but you are allowed to make copies for your own use to critique a book, or do research, etc.

 

Example closer to home - you buy a set of ships plans that you intend to use to build a model. You take the original plans and make two copies. You place the original in protective package, you take 1st copy and glue it to build board, you take 2nd copy and cut-out various parts to use as templates. That's permitted under Fair Use. It's for your personal use (note emphasis).

 

BTW I am NOT a lawyer this is a layman's understanding - As an amateur photographer who did publish my photos I did study the topic.

 

On other note I'm talking about United States Copyright Law - other countries are signatories to International Copyright Law and I don't know how it applies outside the United States.

 

For more information on the US Fair Use Act under Copyright Law see this Columbia University link


Edited by Jack12477, 23 January 2016 - 09:32 PM.

  • Ryland Craze, mtaylor, avsjerome2003 and 5 others like this

Jack
 
"No one is as smart as all of us"
---------------------------------------------

Current build: MS Willie L Bennett
Completed build log(s): MS 18th Century Longboat , AL Marie Jeanne
Gallery: AL Swift , AL Armed Virginia Sloop, AL Santisima Trinidad Captain's Launch , 18th Century Longboat , AL Marie Jeanne
In dry-dock: AL 1798 US Constellation,  MS Picket Boat,  Dumas Donzi Z65 Tournament Fisherman (R/C)

Other: 1912 Hudson River Ice Yacht Manhasset - RESTORATION - Scale = Full Size, Relief Carving for Model Ships


#17
Jim Lad

Jim Lad

    Moderator

  • Moderators
  • 5,239 posts
  • LocationSydney Australia

Just to make life more interesting, remember that this is an international forum - although copyright is recognised world wide, the copyright laws of individual countries vary in detail.

 

John


  • mtaylor, avsjerome2003, CaptainSteve and 3 others like this

#18
overdale

overdale
  • Members
  • 424 posts
  • LocationCentral Virginia

"How about using scanned cut-outs from books?"

 

 

 

It's a very confused subject Peter. I think there is a clause in copyright means you can reproduce for your own personal use, but it's not that clear.

When I was at art school we had an entire day devoted to teaching us the copyright laws. None of us left that classroom any the wiser.. (Not that we were particularly wise to start with!)

 

I have noticed at my local Staples that when I ask for something to be photocopied from a book I own they sometimes ask 'is it my drawing', did I write the book?'  all sorts of bizarre questions that clearly indicate they don't understand the copyright laws either. :huh:

 

Dan.


Edited by overdale, 23 January 2016 - 08:03 PM.

  • mtaylor, flyer, Altduck and 2 others like this

#19
daddyrabbit1954

daddyrabbit1954
  • Members
  • 397 posts
  • LocationTampa, Florida

Now here is another layman's take on it...if the original artist or owner does not take action to stop illegal use of their copyright material, they can actually lose their rights to it. At least that's what I've been given to understand when asking why it's so hard these days to find some of the original company logo decals for particular types of scale models. The mfg. must get permission from the company who owns the rights to whatever it is. Ford, Chevrolet, etc.


  • mtaylor, avsjerome2003, flyer and 3 others like this

#20
Jack12477

Jack12477

    Hard water sailor

  • Members
  • 1,346 posts
  • LocationSaugerties, Mid-Hudson Valley/Catskill Region, NY

Dan, get a copy of the Fair Use Act and wave it under their nose and tell them it falls under that.

The key test under Fair Use seems to be 1.) is it a reasonable number of copies requested, 2.) is it for your own use in research, or critiquing an article or work of art, making a model, 3.) are you the purchaser of the copyright piece (e.g., book).

 

But as Jim Lad points out this is an international forum and international copyright law may differ from US Copyright law - so be careful and when it doubt get legal advice from a Copyright lawyer.


  • mtaylor, overdale, GLakie and 1 other like this

Jack
 
"No one is as smart as all of us"
---------------------------------------------

Current build: MS Willie L Bennett
Completed build log(s): MS 18th Century Longboat , AL Marie Jeanne
Gallery: AL Swift , AL Armed Virginia Sloop, AL Santisima Trinidad Captain's Launch , 18th Century Longboat , AL Marie Jeanne
In dry-dock: AL 1798 US Constellation,  MS Picket Boat,  Dumas Donzi Z65 Tournament Fisherman (R/C)

Other: 1912 Hudson River Ice Yacht Manhasset - RESTORATION - Scale = Full Size, Relief Carving for Model Ships





0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users

Welcome GUEST to the Model Ship World Community.
Please LOGIN or REGISTER to use all of our feautures.